Uncovering the Next Generation's Hall of Fame


Mariah CareyNot in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame | |||||||||||||||||||||
Eligible since: 2016First Recording: 1990Nominated: 2024 2025Previously Considered? Yes what's this? |
|
Songwriters Hall of Fame: 2022
Inducted into Rock Hall Projected in 2031.
R.S. Top 500 Albums (?) | Rank | Version | |
The Emancipation of Mimi | 389 | 2020 |
R.S. Top 500 Songs (?) | Rank | Version | |
Fantasy (1995) | 419 | 2021 |
Essential Albums (?) | Wikipedia | YouTube | |
Mariah Carey (1990) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Emotions (1991) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Music Box (1993) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Merry Christmas (1994) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Daydream (1995) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Butterfly (1997) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Rainbow (1999) | ☆ | ☊ | |
The Emancipation of Mimi (2005) | ☆ | ☊ |
Essential Songs (?) | Wikipedia | YouTube | |
Vision of Love (1990) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Love Takes Time (1990) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Emotions (1991) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Make It Happen (1991) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Dreamlover (1993) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Hero (1993) | ☆ | ☊ | |
All I Want for Christmas Is You (1994) | ☆ | ☊ | |
One Sweet Day (1995) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Always Be My Baby (1995) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Fantasy (1995) | ☆ | ☊ | |
When You Believe (1998) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Heartbreaker (1999) | ☆ | ☊ | |
We Belong Together (2005) | ☆ | ☊ | |
Don't Forget About Us (2005) | ☆ | ☊ |
Mariah Carey @ Wikipedia
Will Mariah Carey be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame? "Musical excellence is the essential qualification for induction." |
Comments
40 comments so far (post your own)Well, It's tough to say. Posted by Erock on Tuesday, 06/11/2013 @ 15:06pm |
no dice! Lip syncher. Posted by Benny on Monday, 07/1/2013 @ 15:18pm |
Pop music lovers...it might be time you start your own hall of fame and stop polluting Rock & Roll history with your crap! Posted by Tony on Friday, 08/8/2014 @ 06:05am |
Mariah falls into the category of easy listening, in the tradition of Barbara Streisand, Barry Manilow, Air Supply, and Julio Iglesias. Posted by Barry on Friday, 12/12/2014 @ 08:49am |
Mariah is indeed a living legend and has contributed so much to the industry,It's only fair that she receive this induction. Posted by Michael Paul on Monday, 06/8/2015 @ 21:09pm |
Of course, Mariah should be inducted. She's tackled every genre of music almost (including Rock...some of her top songs are by rock bands/artists). She's inspired generations. Like all artists, the star might dim as musical tastes change, but she's managed to keep up for decades up until now. Even now, she's still is offered more gigs than anyone that came out with her in the 90's. The RRHoF would be missing a true gem if they passed up on her regardless of what anyone else says to the contrary. You can't argue with success, talent, nor perseverance. Posted by Brandon on Thursday, 07/30/2015 @ 09:05am |
Mariah Carey will make the RRHOF in the 2020-2025 time frame. Vision Of Love came out and this young attractive singer with the soaring voice made people take notice. Her 90's CD Discography is impressive with hit after hit Someday,I'll Be There with Trey Laurens, the Christmas song, Emotions, Hero etc. Posted by |
Let's see...18 #1 hits on the Billboard Hot 100 which topped the previous record of 17 by Elvis (for a solo singer, The Beatles have 20.) and (including airplay only hits), basically has about 45 hits songs to her name. The first female artists to get 4 #1 hits off an album (and a debut album for that matter). Won Best New Artist of 1990 @ the 1991 Grammys (making up for the Grammy's hideous error of 'Milli Vanilli" the year before. Aside from these chart statistics and other awards, she's a vocal phenomenon! Posted by Walter on Wednesday, 03/28/2018 @ 17:16pm |
P.S. - To the guy that said rock and roll is better than R & B. Rock and roll came from R & B in the first place...duh! Posted by Walter on Wednesday, 03/28/2018 @ 17:22pm |
Actually Walter, Elvis had 18 as well. Some weeks Don't Be Cruel was listed as the A-side, some weeks, it was Hound Dog, so music historians are generally agreed that both sides were individual #1 hits in their own respects. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 03/28/2018 @ 23:59pm |
Oh dear christ no. She's effing dreadful. She is insipid and lame. If you are going to put her in there, you had better put Whitney Houston in there first. It's the same sort of schlockey BS. Next people will be saying Beyonce belongs in there. UGH. Posted by Gary on Saturday, 12/29/2018 @ 20:33pm |
It'd be a travesty if she wasn't nominated or inducted! Mariah writes, sings and produces all of her songs (except her covers) and has the most diverse, eclectic discography of any female artist in recent memory (despite fundamentally being an R&B artist, she has experimented in genres such as Jazz, Soul, Gospel, Rock and EDM as well as midtempo and uptempo Pop.). Just listen to the diverse soundscape covered in her latest critically acclaimed album, Caution - tracks like 'GTFO' experiment in fusing EDM with modern R&B, 'Giving Me Life' is post-modern psychedelia at its finest! Posted by Lilly on Sunday, 05/12/2019 @ 17:10pm |
Certainly not going to be a popular opinion here, but in my opinion, Mariah Carey is a terrible singer. Vocally, she has range, but to me, singing is not about being able to hit notes, but being able to communicate emotion. Posted by eric tompkins on Monday, 05/13/2019 @ 21:12pm |
"Certainly not going to be a popular opinion here, but in my opinion, Mariah Carey is a terrible singer. Vocally, she has range, but to me, singing is not about being able to hit notes, but being able to communicate emotion." - Posted by eric tompkins on Monday, 05.13.19 @ 21:12pm Posted by Michael W. on Wednesday, 01/15/2020 @ 15:00pm |
They say musical excellency is basically the overall parameter in getting in the Hall. For 30 years she's been doing just that and her 2018 album Caution proves she is still able to produce quality work and unlike many other artist and RRHOF inductees of the past, not rely on her past hits to show for her current state. Even if that wanst the case however, her legacy is one of the strongest in music history and is up there with the Barbra's, Aretha's and Whitney's- two of which are inductees now. "All I Want for Christmas Is You" going number one this year and extending her reign atop the charts just shows her longevity and ability to stay a A-lister for multiple decades. A true, living legend who deserves her props for being one of music's finest artists. Posted by ABJ on Wednesday, 06/17/2020 @ 16:33pm |
She recently revealed that in the '90s she performed on an alternative rock side project for the band Chick, including writing, producing, and singing backup vocals for the entire album. Does this change anything about her candidacy since I imagine one of the main criticisms is that she isn't rock enough? To be sure, this sounds like a lot of other contemporary stuff from Liz Phair to Hole to Alanis Morissette so it probably doesn't score points for innovation, but it probably does show some versatility that people didn't know she had: Posted by |
There is zero reason to put her in. I mean, seriously? She can't even sing anymore.. not that she was ever that good to begin with, her vocals have always been emotionless. She's just some lady that sings Christmas jingles every year before fading back into complete obscurity. Posted by Thomas on Sunday, 04/11/2021 @ 07:08am |
Her stripping on TRL must be the most rock n roll moment ! Posted by Kenny on Tuesday, 12/14/2021 @ 03:43am |
The amount of revisionist history her fanclub has stated is quite funny but not a surprise too since her fanbase aren't well researched on singing and music in general. Posted by JCrash on Tuesday, 05/17/2022 @ 12:07pm |
Some fans just ranked Mariah up with Aretha and Barbra as being just as influential as the two? Wow and I saw another die hard fan claiming Mariah is a virtuoso which says it all that they know nothing about music Posted by JCrash on Tuesday, 05/17/2022 @ 13:25pm |
Mariah Carey is not even a legend, outside of her delusional fanbase, no one sees her as a "legend." Posted by TheRockSays on Tuesday, 06/7/2022 @ 06:46am |
Hahahaha good joke Posted by Wayne Wilson on Tuesday, 06/7/2022 @ 09:57am |
Mariah changed the sound of popular music by blending rap and r&b/pop together. Not to mention her melismatic singing is the standard now. 19 #1's and 18 of them self penned - induct her !! Posted by Manuel on Saturday, 11/19/2022 @ 15:31pm |
Mariah is a phenomenal talent that is able to sing, produce and write every one of her songs, of which she had many hits. Y'all can say what you want to try and discredit her but she had SO much to do with her OWN success. She came from nothing and is now residing at the top. Her contemporaries can't say that they wrote, sang and produced their entire discography. She absolutely deserves her spot in the Rock and Roll Hall of fame. Posted by Jimmy on Thursday, 01/5/2023 @ 14:24pm |
Honestly if Mariah wasn't a Biracial female pop diva, her induction wouldn't even be questioned. Posted by Marinette on Friday, 02/3/2023 @ 13:20pm |
You are spot on about Mariah. I hope that if she is ever inducted, it will be before she leaves this earth. It's sad that the industry seems to have some kind of vendetta against her. With her influence on many artists, her catalog, songwriting, producing and not to mention vocals skills, it should be a no brainer that she be inducted. It makes me wonder what do they (The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame committee) really consider when making their decisions on nominees and inductees. Posted by Wannie on Friday, 02/3/2023 @ 19:19pm |
You'd think making the most iconic (and annoying) Christmas song ever that literally recharts on the Billboard Hot 100 every year would keep Mariah Carey open in the eyes of the voters, but I guess not. Posted by Jagger on Thursday, 02/9/2023 @ 08:41am |
Since I'm on one right now, I'll just drop this quote from Wikipedia: Posted by Jagger on Thursday, 02/9/2023 @ 08:49am |
"If someone described to you all of those accolades *before* telling you the artist name you'd assume they were not only a Hall of Famer, but a first-year inductee. I know record sales aren't everything, but the sheer cultural presence she had makes all the question on her own. Her discography and work compares pretty favorably with many other Hall of Famers. I am gobsmacked at this." Posted by Jagger on Thursday, 02/9/2023 @ 08:51am |
It's because boomer critics didn't like her when she was current. I don't believe Robert Christgau was ever on the Nominating Committee but he hung out in the same social circles with most of the critics on it, and look at how he reviewed her: Posted by |
Sean this is a fantastic write-up and I agree 100% with it. You're right that what's going on here is more rockist than racist, but man, either just shows the lack of imagination going on with the nominating committee. Posted by Jagger on Thursday, 02/9/2023 @ 13:04pm |
Mariah checks every box when it comes to making it in. She has influence, longevity, commercial success, and yes even critical acclaim (particularly in recent years). Posted by D on Thursday, 04/20/2023 @ 23:52pm |
I think it's obvious at this point that Mariah is blacklisted by the committee members and will not be receiving a RRHOF induction. To say that she has never been nominated, it's clear that she is blacklisted. When you have artists in their first year of eligibility get inducted, she has been such a big part of the music industry for a while now. With the songwriting, producing, singing, influencing, trailblazing, musicianship etc., she is a legend and is well-deserving of an induction. Posted by Wannie on Friday, 09/22/2023 @ 15:54pm |
I think with this year's nominations for the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame, the one I agree with the most is Mariah Carey. She had more #1 hit songs than anybody except the Beatles and Elvis. She should get inducted. Posted by Brian Schonour on Saturday, 02/10/2024 @ 21:54pm |
Mariah Carey is # 9 in total votes on Future Rock Legends. She's not in the Top 10 in Yes votes, but she's # 6 in No votes. She's the only 2024 nominee for the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame on any of the Top 10 lists on Future Rock Legends. If inducted this year, she will be the only artist Future Rock Legends voters got right this year. Her induction will make way for a new artist to join the Top 10 in voting on Future Rock Legends. Posted by |
Mariah Carey deserves it because she is the Queen of Goddess. She sold 320m albums and singles WW. She wrote all her songs and co-produce her hits. She ruled the 90s and 2000s until she score her 19th #1 classic Christmas hit single "All I Want For Christmas is You." 5 years ago in 2019. It will be 30 years since she release her smash Christmas hit. She got inducted to Songwriters Hall of Fame two years ago. She is the Queen of Music. She did Pop, R&B, Gospel, Hip-Hop, and Dance and Rock. Mariah Carey is Music. Posted by Amie Hampton on Wednesday, 04/3/2024 @ 15:18pm |
I was surprised that Mariah Carey won't be inducted into the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame this year. However I think at some point she will get inducted since she had more #1 hits than anybody except the Beatles and Elvis Presley. At least she was nominated. Even one nomination is better than none. Posted by Brian Schonour on Monday, 04/22/2024 @ 21:38pm |
Songs I hope Cher (if she shows up) will perform: Posted by Elle Dee on Monday, 04/22/2024 @ 22:11pm |
I think Mariah Carey will get inducted to the Rock And Roll Hall of Fame this year. She had more #1 hits than any other artist except for the Beatles or Elvis. Posted by Brian Schonour on Wednesday, 02/12/2025 @ 17:23pm |
I'm so happy that Mariah Carey is nominate for a second time and now its finally big chance she will finally get inducted this. It's gonna 35 years of showbiz. It's finally long overdue. Posted by Amie Hampton on Saturday, 02/22/2025 @ 00:59am |
Future Rock Legends is your home for Mariah Carey and the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, including year of eligibility, number of nominations, induction chances, essential songs and albums, and an open discussion of their career.
This site is not affiliated with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum.