Uncovering the Next Generation's Hall of Fame
Future Rock Legends predicts the 2015
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominees
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Nominating Committee will meet in the next week or so to determine the nominees for the 2015 induction ceremony, which again will be held in Cleveland. The ballot will likely be announced in mid-October.
Future Rock Legends predicts the following sixteen eligible artists will be on the 2015 ballot:
- Green Day - The last time the Induction Ceremony was in Cleveland, Green Day opened the event with one of their own songs. In 2015, they'll likely be back in Cleveland closing the show.
- Nine Inch Nails - There aren't many names left on Rolling Stone's 100 Greatest Artists of All Time list that haven't been inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Trent Reznor's remarkable career (and Cleveland roots) makes this an easy choice. (Side note: Would Reznor be the only person inducted? Has a "band" ever been inducted with one member?)
- N.W.A - Speaking of remarkable careers, how cool would it be to have both Reznor, Beats Music chief creative officer, and Dr. Dre, Beats co-founder, inducted at the same ceremony? Might as well induct Jimmy Iovine as a non-performer too. N.W.A have been nominated every year since they became eligible.
- MC5 - After his rousing speech inducting Kiss into the Rock Hall, we're pretty sure Tom Morello could convince the Nominating Committee to put Milli Vanilli on the ballot, so getting the MC5 on there should be a piece of cake. The MC5 were previously nominated in 2003.
-
Chic - If Chic gets nominated again, that will be how many times on the ballot? Nine times? Nine times.
- Kraftwerk - The Rock Hall didn't put Kraftwerk back on the ballot last year, despite coming in sixth place in the Rock Hall's official fan poll for 2013. With a potential Nine Inch Nails induction this year, it would be a shame if one of the pioneers of electronic music didn't get in too. In addition to 2013, Kraftwerk were on the 2003 ballot.
- Joan Jett & the Blackhearts - Joan Jett's performance with Nirvana at the 2014 induction ceremony was one of the evening's highlights, and should remind the Nominating Committee that they need to keep putting her on the ballot until she gets inducted.
- Deep Purple - Deep Purple has been a top priority for a few people close to the Rock Hall, such as Lars Ulrich and Eddie Trunk, so they should return to the ballot this year, despite the band's ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ attitude towards induction.
- Sonic Youth - Well, Questlove did say he was going to "fight for Sonic Youth" this year. Let's hope so!
- Stevie Ray Vaughan - Joe Bonamassa, Dusty Hill, Derek Trucks and Billy Gibbons jamming during the Freddie King tribute performance at the 2012 Induction Ceremony brought the crowd to its feet. It would be nice to fill Public Hall in Cleveland with the blues once again. Vaughan has never been nominated.
- LL Cool J - LL Cool J seems to have become a fulltime awards show host now, but never forget his importance to launching hip hop in the 80s.
- Roxy Music - Last year, Nominating Committee member Roy Trakin had Roxy Music number two on his wishlist, behind Nirvana. One of the most influential bands to have never made the ballot.
- Bill Withers - Not many R&B artists have appeared on the Rock Hall ballot lately, but Withers is one of the most deserving of a nomination.
- Link Wray - Link Wray finally made the ballot for the first time last year, with Steven Van Zandt being one of his biggest champions on the Nominating Committee.
- Yes - This theory about last year's ballot is just too fantastic to ignore.
- The Paul Butterfield Blues Band - Will Jann Wenner and Paul Shaffer lead the charge to get them on the ballot for the third year in a row?
[Predictions posted September 10, 2014]
Future Rock Legends forecasts which of today's artists will be the next generation's Rock & Roll Hall of Famers by using a combination of historically predictive criteria, user votes, and nomination patterns. The official nominees are determined by the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Foundation's Nominating Committee.
Artists are eligible for the Rock
Hall 25 years after releasing their first record (anyone
with a record released up through 1989). Future Rock Legends lists eligible artists by first year of eligiblity or alphabetically.
You can contact us here and follow us on Twitter here.
Share
Comments
249 comments so far (post your own)http://futurerocklegends.com/2014_Inductees.php#336027 Posted by FRL on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 09:21am |
Here Are My Nominee Predictions Posted by Kyle on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 09:23am |
Once again, here is my list of 2015 nominees, with a slight modification: Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 10:00am |
My predictions for 2015: Posted by Greg F on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 10:16am |
Posted by PopeCharming on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 10:50am |
Here is my predictions for the 2015 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Nominees: Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 21:03pm |
I understand those who support Carole King’s induction as a performer, but I think everyone should realize that she was already inducted in the non-performer category as a songwriter in 1990. I think this was a controversial decision on the Rock Hall’s part, given that King was nominated as a performer on the 1989 ballot. Personally, I think she belongs in the performer category because of her large body of work as a solo performer—especially for her 1971 album Tapestry that included many of her best-known songs. However, I don’t think the Rock Hall will induct a person twice in two different categories; this is something that has never happened nor will I think this could ever occur. So the likelihood of King’s induction as a performer (no matter how deserving) will probably not happen. Instead, I think the support for King should be for her to be the focus of next year’s music masters program. Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 21:13pm |
2015 NOMINEES PREDICTIONS Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 08/6/2014 @ 22:25pm |
So which one are you going with Roy of the 4 choices you made? Posted by Nick on Saturday, 08/9/2014 @ 13:09pm |
I will do two lists of 16 nominees. Posted by Tom H. on Saturday, 08/9/2014 @ 20:10pm |
1. Green Day Posted by Matías Adducci on Sunday, 08/10/2014 @ 12:26pm |
So which one are you going with Roy of the 4 choices you made? Posted by Roy on Sunday, 08/10/2014 @ 19:05pm |
To Tom Lane Posted by Roy on Monday, 08/11/2014 @ 09:41am |
To Tom Lane Posted by Roy on Monday, 08/11/2014 @ 09:43am |
Tom H., Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 08/13/2014 @ 09:50am |
Enigmaticus: Posted by Tom H. on Wednesday, 08/13/2014 @ 10:28am |
Chic Posted by Casper on Thursday, 08/14/2014 @ 14:37pm |
Hmmm...wonder if its too early? Since last year was the first time (and hopefully the only) the nominees were announced, I'm thinking of putting my final 15 until early September or late August. As always the case, this will be another great interesting year. Posted by Jason Voigt on Friday, 08/15/2014 @ 13:57pm |
Whoops I just now noticed I left out the fact the nominees list was put out in October. My bad. This site needs a comment editor :) Posted by Jason Voigt on Friday, 08/15/2014 @ 13:58pm |
What about the cars billy idol weird al 80's line up of kiss Posted by michael odom on Friday, 08/15/2014 @ 22:23pm |
The Cars and Billy Idol, yes. Deserving icons. Weird Al? No, making up adolescent lyrics to other peoples' music is not HoF worthy. The Kiss part doesn't deserve a response. Posted by DarinRG on Friday, 08/15/2014 @ 23:45pm |
The Cars, yes. Billy Idol is a faux punk who is even less deserving of induction than Poison. "Weird Al" does do some adolescent parodies, but some of them are poignant bits of commentary on our society. Plus his original songs/style parodies are usually pretty brilliant. His new album fell a little short of the mark that "Alpocalypse" hit, but it still has some pretty awesome moments. Posted by Philip on Saturday, 08/16/2014 @ 21:52pm |
Once again, here is my list of 2015 nominees, with a slight modification: Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 08/17/2014 @ 05:44am |
Philip sticking up for punk cred. I like it! Posted by DarinRG on Sunday, 08/17/2014 @ 23:18pm |
The next ballot should be and 6 will get in: Posted by Dan on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 08:38am |
That is a great list, Dan. Where is Carole King on that list, however? From your list, I would choose the following artists as inductees: Chicago, Green Day, Yes, The Doobie Brothers and The Zombies. I am not so certain about Deep Purple. The third time might be a charm for them, however Chic may end up getting in with their ninth nomination. Chicago, like KISS before them, might win the public's popular vote. Yes barely missed getting in last time by supposedly 20 votes, or so. According to your list, Yes will be Deep Purple's biggest competition. Green Day and The Doobie Brothers should be shoo-Ins. Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 09:25am |
However, if for some reason, Duran Duran, The Moody Blues and Electric Light Orchestra get nominated, all bets are off. Those three will have their own huge fan bases, receive support from Rush's massive fan base (which had supported KISS last year) and will get quite a few votes from the present membership. How huge, you might ask? The Moody Blues votes could easily displace those of Yes and Chicago, not to mention Deep Purple and The Zombies. Duran Duran and their massive fan base could challenge anyone on that list and win easily. Electric Light Orchestra, specifically their founder Jeff Lynne is iconic. Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 10:04am |
Any 6 of these artists would make a great HOF class of 2015: Posted by GV on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 11:10am |
GV, Posted by Nick on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 15:14pm |
Yes Posted by Brian on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 16:10pm |
A few weeks ago I posted my ballot predictions but since some people seem to be predicting which artists from their ballots will get in this year I figured I'd follow the trend. First off here are my ballots: Posted by Tom H. on Monday, 08/18/2014 @ 18:34pm |
I still think that the Rock Hall will need to do something really spectacular for their 30th anniversary induction ceremony. As the years pass by, artists become older and some may even pass away prematurely. Lou Reed's passing last year was somewhat unexpected and given Rolling Stone Magazine's love for him, he could be included on this year's ballot. Stranger things have happened, but even his widow, Laurie Anderson could receive a nomination as well. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 08/19/2014 @ 10:05am |
If Yes was short of just 20 votes for the 2014 class, it's safe to say that they are a lock for induction for the 2015 class. Yes is the next major progressive rock act that needs to be inducted anyway. This isn't good for Deep Purple or any hard/progressive rock group trying to get in next year because they will be fighting for the same slot. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 08/19/2014 @ 20:17pm |
Rock Hall voting is a prey clandestine affair. Any proof or testimony that says Yes fell only 20 votes short? Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 08/20/2014 @ 00:04am |
The Drummer from Yes said this in a recent interview (I'm sure if this is true or not, but if it is then Yes will certainly be a lock for the 2015 class). Here is the link to the interview: Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 08/20/2014 @ 00:24am |
Meant to say "I'm not sure if this is true or not" (sorry) Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 08/20/2014 @ 00:30am |
Toto deserves a nomination! Is there a way to at least get them on the Public Online Poll in the HOF website? Posted by Leo on Friday, 08/22/2014 @ 13:49pm |
As soon as I post my predictions, I start second-guessing myself. Posted by PopeCharming on Friday, 08/22/2014 @ 16:23pm |
Personally, I don't think Toto warrants a Rock Hall nomination and feel that there many late 1970s and early 1980s musicians that need to be inducted before them. Some names that come to mind include Chic, Duran Duran, Sonic Youth and The Smiths. I just don't find Toto innovative enough nor have they contributed enough to Rock music for the Rock Hall. Posted by Nick on Friday, 08/22/2014 @ 18:03pm |
My guess is as good as yalls Posted by Prince on Saturday, 08/23/2014 @ 04:52am |
The backlog of deserving artists continues to grow and grow. Posted by Mike on Wednesday, 08/27/2014 @ 04:31am |
Hi everyone! Posted by Lax31 on Saturday, 08/30/2014 @ 22:24pm |
Here is my list of nominees for 2015: Posted by Larry on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 07:15am |
16. The Monkeys Posted by Larry on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 07:19am |
You have a much better list of nominees and inductees now Lax31! I could easily choose 5 of those artists. By the way, where did Kate Bush come from? Given your choice of nominees, this would be my inductees list: Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 09:31am |
Once again, here is my list of 2015 nominees, with a slight modification: Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 09:35am |
I still think that the Rock Hall will need to do something really spectacular for their 30th anniversary induction ceremony. As the years pass by, artists become older and some may even pass away prematurely. Lou Reed's passing last year was somewhat unexpected and given Rolling Stone Magazine's love for him, he could be included on this year's ballot. Stranger things have happened, but even his widow, Laurie Anderson could receive a nomination as well. Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 09:39am |
"I still think that the Rock Hall will need to do something really spectacular for their 30th anniversary induction ceremony." Posted by Philip on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 12:01pm |
I doubt the Rock Hall will do anything "special" for the 30th anniversary of Rock Hall ceremonies. Sure, there might be a concert or TV special, but nothing really beyond that. The 30th anniversary will absolutely have no bearing on who's nominated and inducted for the 2015 class (it shouldn't). Phillip, I loved your last sentence about Enigmaticus, someone who constantly posts the same predictions (no matter how slim the chances are for most of his choices) each time on this forum. Also, there will NEVER be 12 inductees in one year ever again so his "setlist" wet dream will never, ever happen (I think 1987 had around 15 inductees, but that was the second year of the inductions). Posted by Nick on Sunday, 08/31/2014 @ 18:26pm |
Nick, Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 17:25pm |
Actually, I did not post that prediction on this forum until June, 2012. I had predicted it elsewhere 5 months beforehand. Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 17:29pm |
Mike Raymond has an interesting list, from his list, I would choose the following as inductees: Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 18:01pm |
Mike Raymond has an interesting list, from his list, I would choose the following as inductees: Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 18:06pm |
September has arrived! Posted by Roy on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 19:31pm |
A lot of pop artists were already inducted, I hope The Carpenters will be nominated. Posted by akeem on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 20:09pm |
The Carpenters definitely deserve a nomination, so I would definitely support that cause. If not this year, I can see them becoming nominees (not necessarily inductees anytime soon) within the next 5 years. Posted by Nick on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 21:03pm |
1ST year Eligible nominee(Green Day Posted by Ben on Monday, 09/1/2014 @ 23:49pm |
My predictions for this year's nominees: Posted by Paul K on Tuesday, 09/2/2014 @ 01:20am |
Paul K, Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 09/2/2014 @ 04:31am |
Can't support an induction of Chicago into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. After Terry Kath died, Chicago was Air Supply with horns. Posted by EricP on Tuesday, 09/2/2014 @ 16:02pm |
Alright...here it is, my 15 picks of who I believe will be nominated for 2015 Induction Ceremony. When I first drew up this list a month ago, I had 25 acts listed. Believe me, it was hard to whittle them down to 15. Posted by Jason Voigt on Tuesday, 09/2/2014 @ 19:29pm |
Excellent writeup, Jason. Will be up in your neck of the woods this weekend for Loufest. Posted by Paul in KY on Wednesday, 09/3/2014 @ 07:52am |
Jason, you could say the same thing about Nirvana because while their first album was released in 1988, nobody outside of Seattle heard of them until the release of 1991's Nevermind. This is why I think you're wrong here when trying to apply this to Green Day. Yes you are right that didn't become successful until 1994, but it's the first year that they put out a record that counts. Voters looked past Nirvana's year, it's the quality of their music and their influence on rock music that truly matters (not the year they "made it"). Green Day will be a sure-fire first-ballot Hall of Famer, they are virtually a lock at this time. I agree with you that Nine Inch Nails deserves to be first-ballot hall of famers as well, but something tells me that they won't get inducted for another couple of years given the stacked number of worthy inductees in the last couple of years. Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 09/3/2014 @ 22:54pm |
My predictions of this year's nominees: Posted by Ian on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 00:41am |
Something that concerns me about the big-name alternative rock bands of the 90's that are already eligible or will be eligible in the next few years, is the possibility that Soundgarden is going to be left behind. Now I'm aware that there are a butt-load of worthy HOF rock bands of the 80's that were in the underground (Sonic Youth, Pixies, Replacements, etc) that are also getting left behind, but that's another subject for another time. In this one I'm talking about the mainstream, big time rock acts of the 90's. Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 08:03am |
Great discussion topic, Donnie. Yeah I was kind of worried about Soundgarden too, since they came out way before the words 'Seattle grunge' were in our vocabulary. In 1989, Soundgarden released their first so-called major label LP, so maybe that would raise our hopes a bit. Posted by Jason Voigt on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 12:04pm |
"Everyone's predicting that Green Day and Nine Inch Nails will both be on the ballot this year." Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 13:49pm |
Nine Inch Nails is on both of Rolling Stone's Immortals lists. In the bottom 10, but still. Green Day is nowhere to be found on the list, as of yet. Just thought I'd throw that out there Posted by Jason Voigt on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 14:39pm |
I agree with Darin. I haven't made my predictions yet, but NIN won't be among them. Fantastic and important band that deserves it, but I don't see them at the top of their wishlist. Same goes for Soundgarden or Alice in Chains, by the way. My prediction is that none of these bands will make the ballot before Pearl Jam is inducted. Posted by The_Claw on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 14:44pm |
Jason - That is an interesting point, but I also think that Rolling Stone lists or RS critical praise translating to the NomCom's agenda can be overstated. RS loves a lot of the snubbed 80s bands, but it doesn't seem to sway the NomCom much. Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 16:17pm |
You also can't overlook the fact that Green Day (or a member thereof) has been on hand to induct at least two relatively recent rock acts (the Stooges and Guns N' Roses)... they're currently in good graces with someone at the foundation. The favor's getting repaid. Posted by Philip on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 23:00pm |
"they're currently in good graces with someone at the foundation. The favor's getting repaid." Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 09/4/2014 @ 23:20pm |
Great discussion guys. Posted by Donnie on Friday, 09/5/2014 @ 08:46am |
Yes too early for NIN. There should be a pecking order when it comes to Alt rock bands. They look like a family tree and the grandparents should be in before for grandkikds and so on.. I feel it is time for a band like Depeche Mode to get in. They continue to produce cutting edge music and draw massive crowds on tour. However I would understand if they don't, there are even bands on the family Alt tree that came before them that influenced bands of the early 80's like The Cure, Depeche Mode and The Smiths). I think you have to look at Roxy music and Kraftwerk for induction before Depeche mode and so on. And then some day NIN and other bands of that generation would get in after Joy Division/New Order, The Cure, Depeche Mode, The Smiths and Sonic Youth etc... Posted by brian on Friday, 09/5/2014 @ 15:52pm |
I agree with those that feel bands like Kraftwerk, The Cure and The Smiths deserve to be inducted very soon. I think Depeche Mode might appear on the 2015 ballot, almost similar to Peter Gabriel and Hall & Oates (obviously worthy candidates who happen to get inducted when they first appear on the ballot after years of getting snubbed). It wouldn't shock me if Depeche Mode appeared (and got inducted) on the 2015 ballot. I think we're gonna see more 1980s bands/acts that are worthy receive nominations for the first time and get inducted on their first appearance. Posted by Nick on Saturday, 09/6/2014 @ 00:22am |
So, I may be late to the party, but I've finally come up with my list of predictions for the 2015 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Class. Last year's class had 16 nominations so that's what I went with. Here they are in alphabetical order.... Posted by Donnie on Saturday, 09/6/2014 @ 07:47am |
My 2015 ballot choices in no particular order: Posted by danny on Saturday, 09/6/2014 @ 17:47pm |
Also: Posted by danny on Saturday, 09/6/2014 @ 17:57pm |
MY LIST - UPDATED Posted by Roy on Saturday, 09/6/2014 @ 20:20pm |
Danny, give it a rest about hip-hop and rap in the Rock Hall. There are already 4 hip-hop/rap inductees (Grandmaster Flash, Run-DMC, Beastie Boys and Public Enemy), so at this point this is a hangup you will have to sort out yourself. There will likely be a hip-hop/rap inductee for 2015 (either N.W.A. or LL Cool J has the best chances as of now) and more in the upcoming years. With more 1990s artists, expect to see them more on future ballots (whether you like it or not). From skimming through your list, you only listed white performers for nominees which will never happen (yes, the performers inducted in 2014 were not black, BUT black artists were nominated such as Chic, NWA, LL Cool J and The Meters). Posted by Nick on Sunday, 09/7/2014 @ 13:19pm |
Forgot to delete that sentence in 3rd paragraph of my post. Sorry about that. Posted by Nick on Sunday, 09/7/2014 @ 13:20pm |
My picks: Posted by Sam on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 07:29am |
The Hall of Fame is so politically correct that it makes we wanna puke. Because they're so he'll bent on inducting rap/hip hop acts to appear less prejudiced, they stray away from the whole of rock and roll. Because Public Enemy and Grandmaster Flash got in, actual rock bands like Yes and Deep Purple get hung out to dry. Why can't there be a rap hall of fame and just leave themselves out of this organization altogether. Posted by danny on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 14:03pm |
Danny, Posted by Paul K on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 14:28pm |
Danny, you gotta understand that "Rock" music means different things to different people. I could argue that progressive rock really isn't a form of rock music because much of the emphasis on that sub-genre involves classical music. Of course I don't agree with the previous sentence but many people do and that is perhaps a reason why many progressive rock bands are kept out of nominations and inductions for the Rock Hall. Likewise, Jazz isn't something that many people would consider in relation to rock music. That is why when Miles Davis was inducted back in 2006, that left many people starching their heads as to what constitutes rock music. Rap and Hip Hop are extension of the Blues (which also served as a precursor to the advent of rock and roll music in the mid-1950s). There shouldn't be a separate hall of fame for rap music nor should that be one for R&B music (the one that just started last year). Rock music is a very vague term for popular music since 1953/1954, so in many ways the Rock Hall is meant as a representative for popular music. Rock music's definition has and will always expand. Race and "political correctness" has nothing to do with rap and hip hop in the Rock Hall. Think about the inaugural class of 1986 and 1987---there were more black performers inducted in those two years than white performers. 2005 and 2009 come to mind as well with years being that the majority of inductees were black. Race has nothing to do with the selection, it's the influence and talent about these performers. This debate has gone on long enough and if you fight against rap and hip hop, you will be in a losing battle. Posted by Nick on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 14:30pm |
Paul K, that is a good point to bring up that it does seem sexist that the Rock Hall almost always insists on at least one female performer per year. I agree with you that all of them deserved an induction, but would they have gotten in as easily if they were male performers? This is where I think you are on to something that the Rock Hall needs to fill quotas. However, you have to keep in mind that one of the biggest criticisms against the Rock Hall is the lack of women who only constitute maybe 3 or 4% of the total number of Rock Hall inductees. This might be the reason why they emphasize more women becoming inductees. Posted by Nick on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 14:36pm |
I can see this being a year that they choose to push through a lot of backlogged artists, as none of the first-year eligible acts are slam dunk first-ballot HOF'ers. Posted by Johnny DuBiel on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 18:52pm |
Paul- I understand what you mean, but I see Darlene Love, Laura Nyro, and Wanda Jackson (Influence) not as women put in for the sake of including more women, but hobby horses that a few members on the Nom Com have-- in the same category as Solomon Burke, Del Shannon, Percy Sledge, Gene Pitney, and others who kept showing up on the ballot indefinitely. Posted by PopeCharming on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 19:31pm |
Induct the old timers now and then induct the rap/hip hop and recent musicians. It's an embarrassment that Public Enemy is in and not Yes or that Green Day has a better chance at getting in this year than Deep Purple. Posted by danny on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 20:14pm |
PopeCharming, that's definitely a valid counterpoint that made me think a little. The Nom Com needs to take a break from their pet projects for a few years, and push fan favorites (the past year was promising, at least nominations wise). It'd be healthy for the Hall's reputation to have at least one or two years of pure backlog killing. At any rate, those three women you listed, plus Kate Bush should've got in before the three I listed. Posted by Paul K on Monday, 09/8/2014 @ 23:45pm |
ROCK and ROLL HOF. nuf said. how about some rock groups for a change!! Posted by Dan on Tuesday, 09/9/2014 @ 03:47am |
Nick: I think Miles Davis got into the HoF almost exclusively on "In A Silent Way" and "Bitches Brew." If he didn't move into Jazz Fusion I doubt he would have been inducted. I personally still think an Early Influence/Musical Excellence induction would have been better. Posted by Gassman on Tuesday, 09/9/2014 @ 09:36am |
Gassman, I think you misunderstood my earlier post. I believe Miles Davis deserved induction, I just meant to say that people who question specific music genres that are in the Rock Hall. I like how you argue that Davis took a jazz fusion turn which is probably what made him an inductee. Like classical music's influence on progressive rock, I just meant that some might question why jazz is in the Rock Hall. I don't advertise this idea, but many do. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 09/9/2014 @ 22:56pm |
I'll take a stab at a prediction of: Posted by DarinRG on Wednesday, 09/10/2014 @ 17:27pm |
Gassman - I didn't question the early blues progenitors. Reread what I said. I said I understand the entry of the early acts that were formative to R&R. What I don't understand is how disco, rap, and "one hit wonders" can slip in to a ROCK and ROLL HOF without the acts (and many more) that I listed having a seat. Posted by Dan on Wednesday, 09/10/2014 @ 19:20pm |
Who should be on the nomination list for the R&RHOF for 2015… Posted by GB on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 02:57am |
Since the majority of music fans want to see their generation's artists get inducted into the HOF, an equitable solution is to induct six A-List artists whose music comes from the last four decades (70's, 80's, 90's & 00's) and covers a broad range of styles i.e. pop, rock, hard rock, soft rock, R&B and alternative. In some of these artists cases they made famous songs in more than just one decade-which in itself supports their worthiness for enshrinement all the more. Posted by GV on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 05:17am |
Those are great nominee lists: Dan, Danny, Sam, GB and yes, even DarinRG and Johnny DuBiel. Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 07:26am |
Regarding progressive rock acts, Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 07:51am |
So after reading Future Rock Legends' predictions as well as those of alexvoltaire (the link to his blog on his predictions is on the link Future Rock Legends gives under Yes), both make plenty of good arguments for artists I didn't put on my nominations list. I'd like to discuss and make a few comparisons between their lists and my list (which I'm still planning on making a more detailed blog of on my Facebook page). Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 08:21am |
So with a few changes made to my list of predictions, here are the 16 artists I'm predicting will be nominated for the 2015 class of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 08:25am |
Of my list, if I was choosing the 6 inductees, I would go with the following... Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 08:37am |
Hi Donnie...I am Alex Voltaire (with Pope Charming as my other alias on the internet. Which is odd, I suppose, given Voltaire's feelings about popes...) Posted by PopeCharming on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 09:47am |
"Hi Donnie...I am Alex Voltaire (with Pope Charming as my other alias on the internet. Which is odd, I suppose, given Voltaire's feelings about popes...) " Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 10:16am |
Another thing I forgot to mention about Bill Withers is that he has an important supporter on the Nominating Committee. That being Questlove. There's an hour long video of YouTube of Questlove and David Byrne (of the Talking Heads) speaking to a college audience about the art of music, their respective careers and the art of music. It's a great find and an awesome video to watch. Highly recommended. Posted by Donnie on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 10:31am |
My choices for 2015 induction class: Posted by danny on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 10:48am |
"Those are great nominee lists: Dan, Danny, Sam, GB and yes, even DarinRG and Johnny DuBiel." Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 17:40pm |
Enigmaticus, Posted by Nick on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 19:22pm |
Sorry if I'm late for this. This are prediction for the 2015 Ballot: Posted by John R.C. on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 19:26pm |
Nick- Posted by Tom H. on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 19:47pm |
I liked your list Tom H and I think you have one of the more realistic ballot predictions of the people who post on this forum. Like my list it is diverse enough to satisfy all genres and tastes. I think the Spinners have a good chance given that they were nominees a couple of years ago. The Meters might show up as well but I don't think they should be inducted as performers. But rather The Meters should be in the Sidemen category (but that's just my opinion). I would like to see a Chicago nomination as well (I think they are a potential wildcard nominee that might sneak in). Great list and thanks for your great comments on my post. Posted by Nick on Thursday, 09/11/2014 @ 20:08pm |
Nick, Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 09/12/2014 @ 10:12am |
Once again, here is my list: Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 09/12/2014 @ 10:16am |
Categories that get somewhat overlooked most of the time or always: Posted by danny on Friday, 09/12/2014 @ 20:33pm |
Songwriter/folk: Jim Croce Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 01:25am |
Ok. Here is my list of predictions for nominations to the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame. I am not listing all 15 I predict. I will list the ones I predict that I like. This will avoid confusion about what I like and what simply predict. Ok. Here we go. Posted by Ben on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 06:59am |
Ben, good list of potential inductees you want on the Rock Hall ballot. The Marvelettes and Chicago are definitely worthy to note and glad you had them on your list. I will admit that I'm not a big fan of the Doobie Brothers (maybe it's just a generational thing--I'm in my early 20s), but a case could be made for their induction. Sure they made good music but was it influential? That I'm not really sure, but there are several examples of artists who made consistently good music that are in the Rock Hall without being entirely too influential (names that come to mind immediately are Hall & Oates and John Mellencamp---but this can be debated due to personal preferences and tastes). Soundgarden will have to wait until after other 90s acts get inducted like Pearl Jam, Radiohead, Green Day and Beck. That is just the truth, although I can see them appearing on a ballot in a couple of years (just not now). Carole King's 1990 induction as a songwriter/non-performer killed her chances to be an inductee as a performer (this was an error on the Rock Hall's part that I still don't understand). Posted by Nick on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 12:21pm |
That is a great list also, Ben. From your list, I would choose: Yes, Lou Reed, The Moody Blues, Doobie Brothers, Deep Purple and Carole King as inductees. Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 13:17pm |
Personally, I would choose, from my list: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 13:31pm |
But, if the Hall wants to do something crazy and unexpected, they might induct Chicago, instead. I am sure that their fan base has been clamoring for an induction, for a very long time. In which case, the inductees might look like this: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 09/13/2014 @ 13:37pm |
Okay, forget all of the above. Here are the REAL deserving 2015 projected nominees: Posted by Joe on Sunday, 09/14/2014 @ 14:32pm |
I realized that my prediction did not sync with what I had on my blog, so here is my final prediction: Posted by PopeCharming on Sunday, 09/14/2014 @ 21:00pm |
Here are my predictions for the 2015 Nominees: Posted by Andrew on Monday, 09/15/2014 @ 18:05pm |
"Nine Inch Nails- Industrial rock at it's finest." Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 09/15/2014 @ 19:30pm |
Excellent list Andrew with logical choices for each of the performers. You chose all my picks expect for Stevie Ray Vaughn (who I think definitely deserves to be nominated and inducted, but he keeps getting snubbed by the Rock Hall so I'm not sure when will receive a nomination at this point). The other nominees that I chose for my list are--Bon Jovi, Paul Butterfield Blues Band, Chic, Jim Croce, Joan Jett & the Blackhearts, Gram Parsons, Spinners and Zombies. Posted by Nick on Monday, 09/15/2014 @ 20:03pm |
"Darin, I think you're being a little nit-picky about Andrew's comments about Nine Inch Nails. I think you're just messing with him thou. That's like if I said Green Day is punk rock at its finest (not my opinion, just an example) and then someone else comments what about Sex Pistols, Ramones and Clash. Andrew's comment was a personal opinion (we all have them, especially on this forum)." Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 09/15/2014 @ 21:03pm |
Nick, in response to your question, the remaining 5 predictions for the 2015 Nominees for me would be: Posted by Andrew on Tuesday, 09/16/2014 @ 00:22am |
Great predictions from a host of people. My 2 cents: Posted by Paul in KY on Tuesday, 09/16/2014 @ 08:03am |
How about: Posted by Mike on Tuesday, 09/16/2014 @ 19:52pm |
I'm going to be posting my prediction on my blog soon... of all the predictions posted that I've read, the two I have the most in common with are JohnnyDuBiel and John R.C., both of whom I match 12 of 16. That's even better than my mid-season report (11 of 15 or 16). JohnnyDuBiel is up to 14 if you include the alternates. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 09/16/2014 @ 20:57pm |
The Zombies MUST get inducted this year. And Bon Jovi MUST NOT...not ever. Posted by Heli0tr0pe on Wednesday, 09/17/2014 @ 22:33pm |
Cheap Trick is long overdue. So are Chicago, Yes, Dire Straits and a bunch of others. But Cheap Trick has got to be in the Hall. Posted by KyPerson on Friday, 09/19/2014 @ 14:14pm |
Has anyone heard anything yet about the Nominating Committee meeting to come up with the nominees. Obviously this is the time frame they usually meet, but does anyone know anything official? Posted by Donnie on Friday, 09/19/2014 @ 18:49pm |
Hey Philip, are you the one that does the Rock Hall Monitors blog? I know Tom Lane, Charles Crossley, and Pope_Charming have blogs, so I'm assuming the Rock Hall Monitors Blog is done by you? Posted by Donnie on Friday, 09/19/2014 @ 18:51pm |
Yep, Donnie, that's me. Posted by Philip on Friday, 09/19/2014 @ 22:09pm |
Yes, the NomCom met this past week. Posted by FRL on Saturday, 09/20/2014 @ 20:50pm |
Well, now we know the Nominating Committee for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has met over the last week or so. I suppose this year has not been as consistent with my posts advocating preferred artists in my quere to be inducted. Rest assured, though; I do have artists that are now eligible that I think and infer will be inducted for the RRHOF Class of 2015. Perhaps now would be the best time to go through each artist or group Future Rock Legends has now predicted will be nominated. Posted by Lax31 on Sunday, 09/21/2014 @ 21:21pm |
Regarding Lax's Deep Purple point: I'm not aware of any Coverdale tensions. In fact, Lord and Paice both played with Whitesnake. I think the problem is Blackmore and the surviving Mk. II members wanting nothing to do with each other. That plus no Jon Lord would make the ceremony a bit more difficult. Posted by Sam on Monday, 09/22/2014 @ 07:56am |
I have my predictions posted at the top of the page but I haven't done inductee predictions if my predictions wound up being 100% correct. I'll post my predictions here again anyway and do my inductee predictions based on that. Posted by Greg F on Monday, 09/22/2014 @ 09:41am |
Because the Rock Hall has gotten more populist in recent years (e.g., Hall & Oates, Linda Ronstadt, Kiss), I think many "popular" acts who have been snubbed in the past are having the best-ever chances of scoring Rock Hall nominations (and possibly inductions). That's why acts like Chicago have a great chance of finally getting a chance into the Rock Hall. I have a feeling that there are going to be a couple of names thrown in that we will all be like "They Deserve to be nominated but we weren't expecting." This is how I felt when I heard last year that Peter Gabriel and Hall & Oates were nominated (They both totally deserved nominations and inductions, but very few thought they stood a chance) and eventual inducted. For some reason, I think someone like Steve Winwood might score another nomination this year, the last time he was nominated was 2003 so he has some leverage to secure another nomination. Something I feel that the "Future Rock Legends 2015 Predictions" lacks is solo artists. I don't think Bill Withers, Roxy Music, Stevie Ray Vaughn or MC5 will appear on the 2015 ballot. Sure they all deserve nominations (and inductions), but I don't see the Rock Hall nominating them this year. On a side note, I can't believe Lou Reed wasn't one of the 16 predictions because of how respected Reed is in the Rock Music community. He just died last year and many rock critics rank Reed among the best front-men and singer-songwriters ever. Reed is a more realistic choice than someone like Bill Withers. If Lou Reed appears on the ballot next month, he will most likely receive induction. Reed is long overdue for induction as a solo artist anyway. Posted by Nick on Monday, 09/22/2014 @ 16:03pm |
Stevie Ray Vaughan was nominated before. Posted by Anonymous on Wednesday, 09/24/2014 @ 21:43pm |
Yes, Joan Jett & the Blackhearts have been nominated twice (2012, 2013), BUT Stevei Ray Vaughan has not received a Rock Hall nomination yet (he should, but he hasn't). Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 09/24/2014 @ 23:07pm |
Yes, Joan Jett & the Blackhearts have been nominated twice (2012, 2013), BUT Stevie Ray Vaughan has not received a Rock Hall nomination yet (he should, but he hasn't). Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 09/24/2014 @ 23:08pm |
I am responding to a Young fellow named Nick. You seem to be very knowledgeable in music. You know about artists from 40 years ago or more. I will reiterate my list as a reminder. Posted by Ben on Friday, 09/26/2014 @ 05:11am |
I want to clarify that my list above is my predictions for Nominees not Inductees. I don't think they will all be inducted. Only about 6 artists get inducted these days. I love early Chicago and they have had a long career. Painfully I still don't think the Hall will be smart enough for that one yet. Same thing with the Doobie Brothers. They can be Nominated not Inducted. I will list Inductee predictions after the Nominees are announced. Joan Jett could be Nominated I think. Same thing. I do however feel Deep Purple will be Nominated and Inducted for example. After all the controversy early in the year over Kiss the Hall may go with a 70s Hard Rock and that consist of quieter fellows. I can see those guys jamming Smoke on the Water at the Hall. I always say the Moody Blues should be inducted and therefore I predict them. I know what you're thinking. Deep Purple and Moody Blues at the same time Why not? Heart and Rush went in at the same time. So anyway this is a Nominee list not an Inductees list. One last example. I predict Yes to be nominated not Inducted. They are too similar to the Moody Blues. Deep Purple is much Harder Rock than the Moody Blues. Posted by Ben on Friday, 09/26/2014 @ 06:26am |
The most overlooked entities for the Rock Hall of Fame have to be The Monkees along with Jan and Dean..... Monkees have proven year in year out they are real thing AND how many others have been inducted that used the same Wrecking Crew to do their music??? Jan and Dean are the same, more hits than most, plus Jan Berry was one of the best west coast music minds in the 60's, not to mention you could at least throw him and Dean a bone for coming back from the near death accident in '66. Posted by Gene on Friday, 09/26/2014 @ 12:20pm |
Gene, the Monkees had advantages no other rock band had (Network publicity, Neil Diamond writing songs for you, etc.) Why weren't they bigger? Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 09/26/2014 @ 13:49pm |
I wouldn't mind if inxs is on the ballot Posted by Gio on Sunday, 09/28/2014 @ 19:52pm |
1, Deep Purple Posted by Denis on Sunday, 09/28/2014 @ 23:57pm |
Ben, Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 09:37am |
Ben, Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 09:38am |
That time of year is almost upon us: the fight over who should be nominated, and eventually inducted, into the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame for 2015. Here are my picks: Posted by V.F.T. on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 21:45pm |
That time of year is almost upon us: the fight over who should be nominated, and eventually inducted, into the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame for 2015. Here are my picks: Posted by V.F.T. on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 21:45pm |
Not a bad list, but... Posted by Dezmond on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 23:31pm |
Alright, I guess I should post my predictions. Posted by Dezmond on Monday, 09/29/2014 @ 23:58pm |
Those are great lists, Dezmond & V.F.T. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 09/30/2014 @ 09:09am |
By the way, Alex Voltaire, i would like to applaud you for your great analysis on your blog. Thank you. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 09/30/2014 @ 10:15am |
I'm always surprised by the lack of HoF love for Jethro Tull. Not even one single nomination? I wouldn't argue they're the best band ever or anything, but it seems like they certainly have plenty of classic hits, several stone-classic albums, a unique sound (hello rock flute!), and some lasting influence on today's alt-folkie bands on both sides of the pond. And their longevity ain't bad either. What gives? Posted by Heli0tr0pe on Tuesday, 09/30/2014 @ 21:28pm |
1. Kraftwerk Posted by Boomstick on Tuesday, 09/30/2014 @ 23:14pm |
Enigmaticus, Posted by Ben on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 05:06am |
October has arrived! Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 06:19am |
Green Day Posted by Classic Rock on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 09:07am |
Thank you Ben, Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 09:46am |
Once again, here is my list: Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 09:55am |
Note to self: I could not really come up with alternates to those artists, plus having two different tablet computers is an asset. My old first generation Ipad has a shattered display screen, but it still works. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 10:07am |
What I want to see: Posted by Anonymous on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 14:42pm |
Personally, I think the Rock Hall is starting to move away from 1960s artists at this point. The remaining British Invasion acts that you listed in the previous post don't really have much of a chance at this point (the Moody Blues do deserve a nomination but they have been passed for years and I'm not holding my breath for the Rock Hall to act on this; same with Chubby Checker but his recent comments about wanting an induction might make his chances better than ever at this point, but who knows). I think the Zombies will for sure be the next (and possibly last) deserving British Invasion act to be inducted. Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 15:07pm |
I see some people throwing some Bad Company support out there. Why not Free instead? Posted by Sam on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 18:23pm |
Bad Company most definitely has a better shot than Free. Besides "All Right Now" (Definitely a classic), Free's discography is probably too short for Rock Hall consideration. Bad Company, on the other hand, had a lot of hits in the 1970s. Either way, Paul Rodgers already should be in the Rock Hall because he is one of the greatest lead vocalists in Rock Music history. I would like Bad Company to be concerned, hopefully within the next couple of years. For some reason, I wouldn't be shocked to them appearing on this year's ballot or maybe the 2016 ballot. Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 22:11pm |
Meant to say "considered," NOT concerned. Sorry for the error! Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 10/1/2014 @ 22:14pm |
Regarding Joan Jett: Posted by Classic Rock on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 00:00am |
Enigmaticus. Thank you for your great response. I would definitely support both the induction of the Moody Blues and Yes if they were both nominated.I just feel the way the Hall is only one progressive act will get in at best. I will go with Moodys out of tradition for me and they did come first. It would satisfy having a 60's choice. There was no 60s choice last year. Posted by Ben on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 04:48am |
Ok. Here is my full list of 2015 nominees. I just want everyone to know that I am including ones I don't even like. I am not a big fan of Bon Jovi and I am not into Rap. I do like at least 10 I will list. These are NOT all artists I would like to see Nominated but I feel will be. Ones like Moody Blues and Yes I clearly if people have read my posts. List is Alphabetical. Here we go. My Nominee list for 2015. Posted by Ben on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 06:01am |
My nominee predictions: Posted by rockstar23 on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 06:22am |
You are very welcome, Ben Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 09:49am |
"I appreciate that the Hall wants to include more women, and that's a noble cause. They still have to be a worthy artist, and Joan Jett falls short. Let's debate Carly Simon or Carole King or Dionne Warwick or Janet Jackson. Joan Jett was a very, very average act." Posted by Philip on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 10:33am |
^ Posted by Guru on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 11:12am |
Chicago and The Commodores should be on this years ballot!!Chicago had went strong in 70's and 80's!!The Commodores were Motown's first Funk band and gotta get Lionel Richie going as a 2 time inductee for his great career!! Posted by Robert Henry on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 11:34am |
Good point, Guru. Many people assume Tina Turner is already in, but she is only in as part of Ike and Tina. She should be seriously considered for her solo career as well. Posted by Dezmond on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 12:48pm |
Adding to my list of British Invasion, folk, and early rock seen above: Posted by Anonymous on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 18:42pm |
My predictions: Posted by BSLO on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 19:26pm |
1. Deep Purple Posted by bondo on Thursday, 10/2/2014 @ 23:22pm |
http://www.mtv.com/news/1648917/pearl-jam-radiohead-and-nine-other-surefire-rock-and-roll-hall-of-famers/ Posted by Roy on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 09:11am |
You are very welcome, Ben. Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 09:59am |
I am surprised at the R&RHoF's affection for Joan Jett and the Blackhearts over the Runaways. The Runaways, though all but unknown now, did the woman rocker in black before Pat Benatar, Lita Ford and others. The Blackhearts, as good as they are, had one iconic song, a few other hits, and little else. Posted by Joe on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 10:10am |
Philip, could you please post your list on this forum, or at least post a link to it. Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 10:17am |
Decided to update my nomination predictions. Here is my final prediction (assuming that there are 16 on the ballot): Posted by Tom H. on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 11:33am |
Tom, Chic already has 8 Rock Hall nominations before this year's ballot comes out hopefully within the next week or so. It would be a really dumb move on the Rock Hall to give a lifetime achievement award to Nile Rodgers when his group (Chic) has consisently appeared on the ballot. After all, there are people that want them inducted which is why they keep appaering on the ballot. The Rock Hall just isn't pulling the trigger and letting Chic become Rock Hall inductees. Personally, I want Chic to get inducted this year (not because I don't want them to appear on more ballots in future years), but because they deserve it. "Good Times" alone is one of the most sampeled songs in music history (Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust," Sugarhill Gang's "Rapper's Delight" and Blondie's "Rapture"---Just to name a few) and they had other hits like "Le Freak," "Dance, Dance, Dance," and "I Want Your Love." There is always that stigma against Disco music with some voters that might explain why Chic hasn't already been inducted. With Donna Summer in the Hall, Chic needs to be in the Rock Hall immediately due to their widespread influenced on contemporary music. The Rock Hall should induct Chic for 2015 and I boldly predict that this will be their year. Posted by Nick on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 14:11pm |
Nick- Posted by Tom H. on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 14:36pm |
Glad you agree with me on that; the most obvious example of the Rock Hall misplacing someone in a category is Carole King. She was nominated in 1989 as a performer, but inducted as a non-performer for her songwriting. King should have definitely been inducted as a performer given she had lots of hits on her own. Rodgers getting a lifetime achievement seems wrong like King's situation. This is why King will unlikely ever be a inductee for the performer category because she is already in by her own merit. Posted by Nick on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 18:12pm |
Nick- Posted by Tom H. on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 18:57pm |
For the record I can also see them doing something like this for both Todd Rundgren and Brian Eno Posted by Tom H. on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 18:59pm |
Enig, I was just ribbin' ya, but the link is http://rockhallmonitors.blogspot.com Posted by Philip on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 20:12pm |
Tom, I liked all the predictions you listed. Actually I chose most of the picks you had chosen in a previous posting on this forum several weeks ago. The only ones I didn’t choose was Chicago, Chubby Checker, The MC-5’s and Stevie Ray Vaughn. In my predictions I chose Bon Jovi, Jim Croce, Paul Butterfield Blues Band and LL Cool J instead. I really hope your right about Chicago getting a Rock hall nomination, they really deserve it for their long-lasting popularity from the late 1960s to the 1980s. I think you said it best that if Kiss is able to bypass their criticisms/attacks on the Rock Hall and still get inducted, anything is possible. I think Chicago would definitely be less hostile to the Rock Hall and put their differences aside if they inducted. I think you have one of the more realistic predictions on this forum because I notice that many people tend to pick artists that they “like†rather than artists of more diverse genres/tastes. Like you, I think like a Rock Hall committee member and how they would nominate/induct acts. I really enjoy reading your blog and you have some of the best insights on the Rock Hall that I enjoy reading. Posted by Nick on Friday, 10/3/2014 @ 20:51pm |
Philip, Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 03:36am |
Hey you know what everybody I am modifying my list of nominees for 2015. I listed 15. Last year 16 artists were nominated! Here is my modified and Final list of predictions. Posted by Ben on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 06:27am |
Janet Jackson needs to be nominated! She has been in the business for almost four decades Posted by Kelly L. on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 09:18am |
I just want to clarify. There is often confusion between the Nominee and Inductee predictions. Electric Light Orchestra who I added is an extra Nominee. I do not expect them to be Inducted. Maybe around 2019! There is soo many other artists that will be inducted first I think. As far as Orchestrated and Prog rock I go with Moodys. I will not predict Inductees until Nominees are announced. This way I know who we're dealing with. I just think they may start nominating them. Another key 70s group. Same thing with Chicago and Doobies. As far as Marvelettes also Nominee not Inductee. There's always Oldies on these lists. I think like last year they'll lean to the 70s for Inductees. Just not the ones above. After all L Reed was in the 70s too. I see him as an Inductee. Posted by Ben on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 09:39am |
Ben, Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 10:48am |
Folk/Songwriter: Gordon Lightfoot Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 12:23pm |
Since nobody responded to my earlier list (apparently nobody likes Shaun Cassidy, Milli Vanilli, et al) a more serious list: Posted by Joe on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 20:48pm |
Enig, Carole King wasn't on my list. And you only picked 5, not 6 like with others. My list of 16 was: Posted by Philip on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 21:27pm |
Thank you for the clarification, Philip. Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 21:49pm |
Joe, Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 10/4/2014 @ 22:02pm |
could the MC5, the zombies, dick dale, and/or new york dolls make the nominees list? I hope they do Posted by chris on Monday, 10/6/2014 @ 18:17pm |
http://rockhall.com/inductees/nominees/ Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 10/6/2014 @ 22:09pm |
MY FINAL TWO PREDICTIONS FOR THE 16 NOMINEES Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 10:13am |
Shoot, I think they might actually go the route of Willie Nelson and Joan Baez this year too! Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 10:19am |
MY FINAL TWO PREDICTIONS FOR THE 16 NOMINEES Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 10:28am |
While we're waiting for the 2015 nominees... a proposal: Posted by Future Rock Legends on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 15:21pm |
Sounds like a good idea, FRL. I am fine with it. Posted by Paul in KY on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 15:28pm |
I agree, this sounds like a good idea to pass some time. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 15:54pm |
My predictions for this year's ballot: Posted by Ryan on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 16:57pm |
Good idea. I like the scoring system. Posted by DarinRG on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 19:18pm |
Good points system, but if I may offer one adjustment: Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 19:43pm |
Shouldn't we have a limit on the number of predictions? Posted by Gassman on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 20:25pm |
It should be 16 nominees (the absolute max) for everyone because there were 16 nominees last year. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 20:35pm |
The only thing wrong with FRL's proposed scoring system is the fact that the Hall loves to nominate repeat candidates year in and year out. So getting 10 out of 16 correct, but having them all be obvious newly eligibles (i.e. Green Day) and ballot returnees such as Deep Purple or Chic would only net a user ten points. Posted by Casper on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 20:54pm |
How about we base it on number of prior nominations? Posted by Casper on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 20:59pm |
It is almost the time of year when the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Nominating Committee announce who is being nominated for the newest inductee class; this one for 2015. For myself, this year's predictions and prognostications for whom will be inducted and/or nominated is less focused than in previous years. As many fellow posters know, it had become a tradition, so to speak, for me to predict and hope for an induction of an artist that I had thought well deserved an induction. Well, two years ago, Donna Summer was inducted, albeit just after she died. And last year, Peter Gabriel was inducted. So, who would I next advocate for an induction until they get in? Posted by Lax31 on Tuesday, 10/7/2014 @ 21:44pm |
Once again, my serious wish list, I know that just about all of these will pretty much never be nominated or inducted, ever, at least in my lifetime... :D Posted by Rick Vendl II on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 02:45am |
My actual 2015 Rock Hall Nomination predictions... Posted by Rick Vendl II on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 03:03am |
Look for the nominees within the next 18 hours or so. Posted by FRL on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 14:08pm |
My predictions: Posted by Gassman on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 14:47pm |
When that game was posted last night on this forum, I had a feeling the nominees were gonna be released on Thursday for some time (I'm kicking myself for not posting this last night like I was gonna do). Like everyone else, I cannot wait for the nominees list to come out. Here are my final predictions of the 2015 nominees: Posted by Nick on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 16:00pm |
I may be way off on this but once again here are my final nominee predictions Posted by Tom H. on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 16:16pm |
I could be off a bit but here are my nomination predictions once again. Posted by Greg F on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 18:25pm |
https://www.youtube.com/user/rockhall/videos Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 19:08pm |
http://www.youtube.com/user/rockhall/videos Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 19:10pm |
My final predictions will be: Posted by SotN on Wednesday, 10/8/2014 @ 19:20pm |
Nominees are out! Posted by rockstar23 on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 06:19am |
rockstar23: I genuinely got floored when I saw the Smiths as one of the nominees. I wasn't thinking the Hall of Fame would even consider them. Pleasant surprise, that. Posted by SotN on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 06:23am |
Here are some of my thoughts on the 2015 nominees that were announced this morning: Posted by Nick on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 06:48am |
We got nine right (using 16 picks for 15 slots)... Did anyone get more than that? Posted by FRL on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 13:54pm |
For 2014, I would love to see Sting, Chic, Stevie Ray Vaughan, Lou Reed and War inducted! Bill Withers is super-talented vocally, but it's amazing where I read in the late 70's JET Magazine that he was unfortunately physically abusive to his ex-wife, actress Denise Nicholas of the famed 227. He later remarried and seemingly had a successful marriage with two children. For 2015, definitely Janet Jackson! Posted by Kai on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 22:40pm |
For 2014, I would love to see Sting, Chic, Stevie Ray Vaughan, Lou Reed and War inducted! Bill Withers is super-talented vocally, but it's amazing where I read in the late 70's JET Magazine that he was unfortunately physically abusive to his ex-wife, actress Denise Nicholas of the famed (Correction: Room 222 series). He later remarried and seemingly had a successful marriage with two children. For 2015, definitely Janet Jackson! Posted by Kai on Thursday, 10/9/2014 @ 22:41pm |
Stevie Ray Vaughan was nominated. They did NOT nominate Double Trouble. They corrected nominated Joan Jett and the Blackhearts, though. How disrespectable to Double Trouble!!!!!! Posted by BK on Friday, 10/10/2014 @ 14:40pm |
http://tomlanesblog.blogspot.com/2014/09/2015-rock-roll-hall-of-fame-nominee.html Posted by FRL on Saturday, 10/11/2014 @ 23:38pm |
You guys need to put the doobie brothers and bad company in. They should've been in years ago over rappers Posted by jerry quinonez on Thursday, 11/20/2014 @ 15:17pm |
What about The Cars Posted by rob on Monday, 11/24/2014 @ 19:02pm |
Motley Crue should be on the ballot Posted by Kevin on Tuesday, 12/30/2014 @ 17:51pm |
DEVO gets to be on the list. They have a big following ... AND EVERYONE knows who they are ...easy. Posted by neil on Sunday, 01/4/2015 @ 23:47pm |
how in the world can you overlook some of the artists and bands that ---you do? Posted by mike knapik on Thursday, 04/16/2015 @ 11:41am |
You need to induct Wolfman Jack, the original Funk Brothers Band [all of them]and Casey Kasem into the HoF. Early Influences - John Coltrane, Dizzy Gillespie, Charlie Parker n Count Basie for Cool Jazz,Bebop, Boogie. to Rock n Roll Posted by John Morison on Wednesday, 04/22/2015 @ 17:09pm |
Here's my 16 for 2015 RRHOF nomination. Had to chop it down from 21 to 18 now 16. Posted by KING on Friday, 06/5/2015 @ 23:44pm |
Interesting choices, KING. I'd love for that to be the ballot, but will the Nom Com have 12 first-time nominees on the same list? It could happen, but it defies everything we know, historically. Posted by PopeCharming on Saturday, 06/6/2015 @ 06:53am |
01. Joan Baez Posted by Roy on Saturday, 06/6/2015 @ 07:03am |
KING, Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 06/6/2015 @ 10:43am |
Of course, I still like my list the best: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 06/6/2015 @ 10:52am |
This site is not affiliated in any way with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum or the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation.