Next Year Should Be Smashing Pumpkins Turn for RRHOF
If the Rock Hall doesn't nominate Smashing Pumpkins next year, it really feels like they just hate the band.
Look at what they've done this year:
1. A successful, nearly sold-out arena tour.
2. Billy Corgan appeared at the Songwriters Hall of Fame to induct Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley of KISS. The Songwriters Hall of Fame is arguably an even bigger industry circle jerk than the Rock Hall.
3. Smashing Pumpkins performed at the iHeartRadio Music Festival (Rock Hall board chairman John Sykes is also a top executive at iHeartMedia).
4. A star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
5. Three Rock Hall nominating committee members appeared on Billy Corgan's podcast: Jimmy Jam, Allison Hagendorf, and Matt Pinfield.
6. Numerous Rock Hall inductees (who are also voters) appeared on his podcast, including Richie Sambora, Pat Benatar, Billy Idol & Steve Stevens, Daryl Hall, and Todd Rundgren.
Billy Corgan has pretty much done everything he can to help the Pumpkins get nominated and inducted: coming off a hugely successful tour, repairing relationships with other musicians, and getting more involved in the industry.
I do think he wants that Rock Hall induction. The Pumpkins have more momentum now than they've had since the 2000s, IMO.
But if they still don't get nominated next year, I'll start to think some high place people just don't want them in, period.
Again, with the way Rock Hall voting works, artists who are good but not great in a bunch of different areas actually have an easier path to induction than artists who are truly exceptional in one particular area (which I'd argue matters a lot more when it comes to an artist's actual significance) but lack that broad, cross-genre appeal.
Being generally liked, even if you're hardly anyone's absolute favorite, and landing somewhere around No. 5 to No. 7 on a ton of voters' ballots can get you more votes than being a top-three pick among a smaller group of diehard supporters while being completely ignored by everyone else who is indifferent with your work.