Uncovering the Next Generation's Hall of Fame
The 2014 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductees
The 2014 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees will be enshrined at the induction ceremony on Thursday April 10th, 2014 at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn.
Performers:
Musical Excellence:
Non-Performers:
You can read our inductee predictions here. Keep checking Future Rock Legends for the latest Rock and Roll Hall of Fame news. You can also follow us on Twitter here.
Future Rock Legends forecasts which of today's artists will be the next generation's Rock & Roll Hall of Famers by using a combination of historically predictive criteria, user votes, and nomination patterns.
Future Rock Legends lists eligible artists by first year of eligiblity or alphabetically.
Share
Comments
424 comments so far (post your own)Inductees have been leaked: Peter Gabriel, Hall & Oates, KISS, Nirvana, Linda Ronstadt and Cat Stevens Posted by Gassman on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:11pm |
Oh snap, I hope the Hall and Oates induction is true!!! Congrats to Linda Ronstadt. Interesting Cat Stevens got in. Anyway, wait until tomorrow I guess. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:20pm |
From a personal perspective, there's two that I love, two that I'm indifferent about and two that I loathe, so I guess it evens out for me. Objectively I can't make a self serving case against any of them, though. They all made their mark. Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:24pm |
That's true Darin, can't really hate on this list. They all deserved it. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:31pm |
Hey, Lax! Where did you read that Link Wray is going in as an early influence? Posted by Roy on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:36pm |
The and after Brian Epstein is probably Link Wray in the Early Influence category. Posted by Rick Vendl II on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:40pm |
Why the hell did voters pass on Yes and Deep Purple?! Cat Stevens is in, but not Chic, and they are both nominted for the 2014 Songwriters Hall of Fame as well. Posted by Roy on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:41pm |
I'll say that 2014 is the rockist's year. The only inductee that the rockist will flack about is Cat Stevens. Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:44pm |
No, John R.C., I fear you are mistaken. They will be upset about H&O and Ronstadt too. They're not head-bangin' hard rock, and more importantly they're NOT Deep Purple or Yes. Posted by Philip on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:50pm |
"Responding to DarinRG: your post regarding Paul Butterfield, while sarcastic and admittedly quite humorous and thought-provoking, does bring forth a truth to what I have mentioned. Last year, every RRHOF inductee had previously been inducted into our Revisited/Projected Rock Hall project." - Lax Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 22:55pm |
"I'll say that 2014 is the rockist's year. The only inductee that the rockist will flack about is Cat Stevens." Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:02pm |
True, but DP was one they really had their hopes pinned on this year, even moreso than KISS. Posted by Philip on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:06pm |
Yeah the "purists" won't be happen about Ronstadt and H&O, especially H&O, since they seem to be the only real R&B act in that list (Chic was disco/funk). Not sure about Cat Stevens either because I know he's caught a lot of flack for being a Muslim activist. The purists won't be happy about KISS either lol they're never happy. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:13pm |
I'M SO HAPPY. The second year they've skewed toward my leanings - last year I was praying for Randy Newman, this year I would have voted for Ronstadt, Kiss, Stevens, Gabriel and H&O. So all five of my "potential picks" made it. I've always been supportive of Kiss, too. Posted by DC on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:13pm |
I doubt Chic (I'm guessing Nile and Bernard) will get inducted to the Songwriters Hall of Fame either. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:15pm |
This is one of the worst class of inductees from one of the best ballots. Ain't that a shame. Posted by Al on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:16pm |
I also think this does kinda show how ready the voters are for 80s acts to get in. Granted the Cure lost out, but Gabriel and Hall & Oates both getting in may mean that acts like the B-52's, Depeche Mode, Duran Duran, etc. might get in the first ballot they are on too. Posted by DC on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:17pm |
@DC, I'm thinking Nile will get Musical Excellence or the Ahmet Ertegun Award (I think the Ahmet one goes to songwriters/producers and he and Bernard fit the description). I just have a funny feeling that he's part of the "and..." thing. Who knows though? Maybe it's just wishful thinking. More and more every year I don't know why they try with Chic. I was gunning for them but I'm not upset they didn't get inducted. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:19pm |
I agree with both Darin and Philip, there are two I like (Nirvana and Peter Gabriel), two I hate (Cat Stevens and Hall & Oates) and two I'm okay with (KISS and Linda Ronstadt). For me, I would've replace Cat Stevens with either Chic or Link Wray (if he doesn't get in the Influence category like Lax said). Posted by John R.C on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:20pm |
Andrew Long Oldham, former Rolling Stones manager, will be inducted too. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:27pm |
I mean "Loog" not "Long" lol Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:28pm |
Well, the Cat Stevens induction proved what I argued earlier, that literally every singer-songwriter that's deemed worthy enough for the ballot gets in nowadays. Acts like Laura Nyro, Tom Waits and Leonard Cohen all got in (and deserving so) in spite of next to no commercial performance. Cat Stevens was pretty much the bottom of the singer-songwriter trough, and if he got in so easily, then that bodes extremely well for acts like Gram Parsons, Warren Zevon and Nick Drake. Posted by Casper on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:31pm |
I noticed that the Non-Performer inductees are both managers of two British Invasion giants during the early 60s respectively. Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:38pm |
It's sad that Linda Ronstadt won't be able to show up for the ceremony. :/ I can't imagine having Parkinson's. Wonder how many of Nirvana's members will be inducted. Will it just be the classic lineup (Cobain/Novoselic/Grohl) or would it also include Chad Channing, who recorded for "Bleach". As we know about some inducted groups such as the case with Martha and the Vandellas, all of its members were inducted, and sometimes in the case of the Supremes and Temptations, only the classic lineups were inducted and in the case of the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Jack Irons, Josh Klinghoffer and Cliff Martinez were inducted despite only performing on one or two RHCP albums while others like Dave Navarro (who has something of a legacy himself as member of Jane's Addiction) didn't get inducted. Pat Smear is not considered a member at all so he won't get in, which is a bummer. I like Pat. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:38pm |
Andrew Loog Oldham is yet another inductee that hasn't been enshrined in Rock Hall Revisited/Projected. There's like eight or something. Posted by Casper on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:39pm |
Two I love (Nirvana, Peter Gabriel), one I like (Cat Stevens), and three I'm indifferent about. Looks like they went with the biggest sellers this time, for the most part. I''ve got to say it's a real travesty that Yes and Deep Purple didn't get in. If Link Wray gets the early influence award I would be satisfied. Think about two things, though, and wonder about the future direction of the hall. This is the first all white performer class ever. It is also the first without a somewhat obscure nominee. Posted by scott on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:42pm |
It'll be funnier to see who besides Gene, Paul, Ace and Peter who else in Kiss will be inducted! I hope there's no stupid drama though. Someone hinted Grohl might not show up for the Nirvana induction, I hope not. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:42pm |
Tim, Pat Smear will definitely be there to perform even if he isn't an inductee. His connection to Grohl and the fact that he performed live with Nirvana quite often at the end of their career makes it likely. Posted by Casper on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:43pm |
@Scott, there was an all-white performing class in 2003, 2008 and 2012 (save for the "special inductees"). Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:46pm |
Well that's true about Pat. I just hope Grohl shows up. But I don't know how they're gonna perform. With Cobain, they had something unique. I agree about Paul McCartney, I hope they don't invite him. The E Street Band, I always argued, should've been inducted with Bruce Springsteen. That situation reminds me of when Smokey Robinson got in without the Miracles or when Bill Haley went in without the Comets. Posted by Tim on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:48pm |
So, we definitely will have a Paul McCartney/Nirvana reunion. Why? Because Macca will be at the ceremony to induct Brian Epstein (unless he has something else happening in his busy schedule). Wouldn't be shocked if him and Ringo were the presenters for Epstein and it would be kind of fitting for them to play with Nirvana since Kurt's ideal was always to infuse the catchiness of Beatles songs with the sounds of the burgeoning underground movement (as specfically mentioned by Kurt himself). Posted by Casper on Monday, 12/16/2013 @ 23:55pm |
That should be here: Posted by Gassman on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 00:24am |
Casper, I agree wholeheartedly about Cat Stevens. He's a third-rate singer/songwriter. Better choices would have been Carly Simon, Warren Zevon, Jim Croce...even Don McLean would be a better pick than Stevens. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 00:26am |
Yeah, Courtney fronting Nirvana is the most acceptable, sensible and entertaining scenario. It probably should happen. Posted by Casper on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 00:36am |
Snubs List entries all need to have one year added to their total. New names at "0 Years" are Green Day, Pavement and Nine Inch Nails. Posted by Casper on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 02:12am |
I'm not sure it's an all-white list; isn't Linda Ronstadt Hispanic? Posted by Joe on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 02:38am |
I am very disappointed that neither Deep Purple, nor Yes were inducted. On the other hand, I appreciate the fact that Peter Gabiel and Hall & Oates were finally inducted. I am indifferent towards the inductions of Cat Stevens, Linda Ronstadt, Nirvana and KISS. As far as the inductions of Cat Stevens and Linda Ronstadt are concerned, hopefully this will lead to the nominations of Carly Simon, Carole King, Stevie Nicks and Pat Benatar, in the not too distant future. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 03:10am |
I am very disappointed that neither Deep Purple, nor Yes were inducted. On the other hand, I appreciate the fact that Peter Gabriel and Hall & Oates were finally inducted. I am indifferent towards the inductions of Cat Stevens, Linda Ronstadt, Nirvana and KISS. As far as the inductions of Cat Stevens and Linda Ronstadt are concerned, hopefully this will lead to the nominations of Carly Simon, Carole King, Stevie Nicks and Pat Benatar, in the not too distant future. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 03:11am |
I just can't see how LL Cool J, The Meters,The Paul Butterfield Blues Band, and N.W.A. merited second nominations and The Spinners and The Marvelettes didn't . Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 04:29am |
Enigmaticus wrote: 'Will KISS' induction lead to the nomination of Twisted Sister?' Posted by Sam on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 04:58am |
Bill - I remember that one time that you said the same thing a couple hours ago. Posted by DarinRG on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 05:05am |
A few thoughts: Posted by rockstar23 on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 06:38am |
Holy soft rock 2014! Good class in general, although the lack of Yes, Deep Purple and/or Chic is disappointing. Posted by Josh on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 07:45am |
Eddie Trunk must be ecstatic now. Hopefully, Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley will finally make an appearance on "That Metal Show." Who will induct KISS? Dee Snider, Garth Brooks? ? Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 08:43am |
Peter Gabriel, Kiss and Nirvana will add to the votes for Yes and Deep Purple next year! If you are a two-time inductee, do you get to vote twice? I'm going to email Greg Harris and Terry Stewart that question. Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 08:58am |
Would have liked Yes, Deep Purple and Chic. Kiss is fine despite their whining. Nirvana was a given. Gabriel is OK. Cat Stevens continues the singer-songwriter trend. Posted by astrodog on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 09:43am |
"This is one of the worst class of inductees from one of the best ballots. Ain't that a shame." Posted by Idlewild on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 10:04am |
WTF Yes, Deep Purple and The Zombies got shut out for Cat Stevens and Linda Ronstadt???? At least KISS, and Hall and Oates are in. Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 10:14am |
Okay, never mind, I just looked at the comments on the Rolling Stone article and apparently there's still a lot of people who dispute Kiss' legitimacy. The controversy over Kiss is even bigger than the controversy over Deep Purple and Yes, which is not at all what I expected. Not many comments on the lack of black artists, but you can bet the guy at Digital Dream Door will have a lot to say about that. Posted by Idlewild on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 10:30am |
Someone should forward a list of these random artists/bands to the committee for the HOF, and make them study it for hours until they come to their senses. Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 10:46am |
Sorry forgot Chicago. I know I said to name a few, but they deserved to be mentioned. Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:05am |
My ranking of excitement for each act: Posted by Gassman on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:09am |
lol danny Posted by rockstar23 on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:20am |
"How telling. Not even a single black act on your "wishlist". Props to having Kraftwerk though" Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:29am |
2014 Rock Hall Inductees Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:30am |
Rockstar23, Posted by Chris F. on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 11:44am |
Idlewild, Posted by Gassman on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 12:00pm |
I was just about dead-on at the predictions (about 75% accurate)! Posted by Jason Voigt on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 12:06pm |
This year's just meh for me. Nothing that really rouses muc hstrong emotion - though Deep Purple getting passed over for KISS is annoying. Posted by GFW on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 12:31pm |
Gassman, Posted by Chris F. on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 12:31pm |
Actually... Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 13:18pm |
Idlewild, do you really think that Gabriel's first three records are "safe" and "radio friendly'? I am going to be generous and assume you are not that familiar with his work. Posted by dezmond on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 13:19pm |
Should have said first four records. Posted by dezmond on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 13:20pm |
Should have said first four records. Posted by dezmond on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 13:20pm |
The Hall has effectively erased its last shred of respectability by once again passing up a true innovator and legend like Link Wray. Even if he receives an Early Influence induction, it will be nothing but a mere consolation prize, as Link started his career during the rock 'n roll era and thus belongs in the Hall as a performer. Instead, the Hall of Shame has inducted two acts that possess no actual HOF credentials beyond selling some albums: Cat Stevens (one of the most sickeningly saccharine singer-songwriters of his time) and Linda Ronstadt (a shrill banshee who desecrated both 1950s rock 'n roll staples and classic jazz/vocal pop standards). Then again, what do you expect from an alleged Hall of Fame that passed over Kraftwerk in favor in Randy Newman? Posted by Zach on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 14:25pm |
Wow...... Posted by Jason Voigt on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 14:37pm |
A solid class, though the Cat Stevens induction does come from out of nowhere. Hall & Oates are also a sorta' out of nowhere choice, though I thought they might have a chance say, next yr. Posted by Cheesecrop on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 14:39pm |
The Hall website named Hall & Oates as "Daryl Hall And John Oates". They probably did this renaming so they can let people know that it's just them they're going to induct and not session musicians. Posted by John R.C. on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 16:30pm |
Everyone else has something to say, so I might as well put my 2 cents in. I voted for Peter Gabriel, Nirvana, Link Wray, the Replacements and Deep Purple. I considered Hall and Oates, Linda Ronstadt and the Zombies. Posted by EricP on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 18:42pm |
Zach, may the Force be with you, my brother in rock. Posted by Andrew on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:02pm |
I'm kind of not understanding something. The E Street Band are not getting into the "hall of fame". They are in as musical excellence, which means in the hall they will not be up in the top area with Bruce. This seems very much like an even bigger slap in the face to me. Can anyone please explain how this back handed compliment is a good thing. Posted by John on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:07pm |
https://www.facebook.com/rockandrollhalloffame/photos_stream Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:24pm |
I think Cat Stevens had some great songs, but the problem that I have about his induction is that he's anti-American and essentially he wants all Americans dead, that's why he's not allowed in the U.S. Jann Wenner and his liberal buddies don't consider that in their voting, and because of that, the Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:25pm |
I think Cat Stevens had some great songs, but the problem that I have about his induction is that he's anti-American and essentially he wants all Americans dead, that's why he's not allowed in the U.S. Jann Wenner and his liberal buddies don't consider that in their voting, and because of that, the Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:25pm |
Cat Stevens is allowed in the U.S. now. Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:33pm |
Another thing, I saw The Zombies in Central Park for free over the summer. It was my second time seeing the group, and my third time seeing Rod Argent. For musicians who are entering their 5th decade of music, they sounded like they were 20. They played old and new songs and they were just amazing. To hear of their snub is outrageous. The HOF is a sham Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:43pm |
http://www.today.com/video/today/53852141/#53852141 Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 19:44pm |
Eric P. and Danny-- I couldn't disagree more. Cat Stevens is an observant Muslim, but he is nobody's radical or militant. He's spent the last three decades largely doing humanitarian work and promoting peace. If you are going to bash him for getting mistakenly put on the No-Fly List and for a stray comment he made during the Salman Rushdie days, I think you need to get off your high horse before you get a nosebleed. Posted by PopeCharming on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 20:12pm |
@PopeCharming Posted by danny on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 20:47pm |
Maybe it's just me, but I'm just not seeing much interest this time around. Rock fading as cultural force is clearly one factor. But they are also inducting retreads and also-rans. So they have inducted Nirvana. And then they will induct Pearl Jam. And...then what. Posted by astrodog on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 21:17pm |
"Does that make me a racist? I hope you're kidding." Posted by rockstar23 on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 21:36pm |
Interesting comments. I know I whined quite a bit about Cat Stevens... I still think he is the least worthy inductee including the other categories. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 22:16pm |
I have been away for the last 24 hours with important matters having to attend to. Now that the RRHOF Class of 2014 is enacted, here are my comments on each inductee. Posted by Lax30 on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 22:28pm |
Nirvana: an obvious yes. Posted by Nate on Tuesday, 12/17/2013 @ 22:40pm |
"From Everybody on FRL Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 02:02am |
As far as the Rock Hall Official Poll is concerned, I had voted for the following artists for the 2014 induction: Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 02:36am |
What will be the end result of these inductions? Was Rush's induction a game changer? Will we now see the nomination of more progressive rock acts, as a result? I find it quite interesting that 5 acts had direct, or indirect ties to Rush: Nirvana, Yes, Deep Purple, Peter Gabriel and Kiss. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 02:54am |
^ Hopefully Roxy Music. Posted by rockstar23 on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 04:49am |
^ Hopefully Roxy Music. Posted by rockstar23 on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 04:49am |
Bill, you say whatever the Hell you want to say (and I know you will). Posted by Paul in KY on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 07:56am |
Thanks, Paul. Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 13:10pm |
The voters might as well forget about Chic. If they couldn't get in this year then something's up. I do believe, however, if there would have been a 7th inductee this year they probably would have been it. But we'll never know.... Posted by Jason Voigt on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 16:05pm |
Chic will have their 9th nomination the next time they're on the ballot (which is inevitable). Solomon Burke is the only other artist to surpass 8 nominations. He had 10. Posted by Casper on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 16:37pm |
Next year's ultimate Hall Ballot (Top 16 Artists In Our Rock Rankings): Posted by Casper on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 18:09pm |
Nice, Casper. Great stuff as always. Posted by FRL on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 18:29pm |
Bill, while I'm not this "Everybody" clown, I do just want to ask. Since you have a much more inclusive list of classic R&B/soul acts that you'd like to see inducted, may I ask where's the line? Who's "not important enough" to merit induction? I just ask because you've seen me disagree with some of the artists you've touted, and I was curious. As an example, take girl groups. You know I want the Marvelettes in, and the Chantels, and would even love to see the Chiffons, Crystals, and Shangri-Las get in at some point. But I draw the line at the Angels. "My Boyfriend's Back" is an important song, and "'Til" is a song that's been covered by a lot of vocal groups and solo vocal performers, but overall, the Angels fall just shy of the mark, imo. So, for you and classic R&B/soul... who just misses making the grade for you? That's an honest question, not baiting you or anything. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 12/18/2013 @ 22:24pm |
...Are you SURE it wasn't you ? Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 03:16am |
I wonder if the nominating committee will handicap the ballot in favour of Chic next year the same way they practically ensured Linda Ronstadt's induction by not nominating any other woman. Posted by rockstar23 on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 05:02am |
Ladies and Gentlemen, for those of you who may not be familiar with latest random female to be enshrined in the RRHOF, here is the mediocre, shrill banshee (as she has been described by various posters on to this site) AKA Linda Ronstadt desecrating a 1970s fan favorite: Posted by Richie on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 12:13pm |
And here is Ronstadt again. More sacrilege to a classic oldie. This time she seems to be dealing a devastating blow to the song's author. Posted by Richie on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 12:24pm |
and more sacrilege by Ronstadt which seems to have dealt a devasting blow to the song's author: Posted by Richie on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 12:25pm |
"...Are you SURE it wasn't you ? Posted by Philip on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 13:04pm |
You really do need to relax more. Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 14:28pm |
I've enjoyed reading all the comments BOTH PRO AND CON regarding the 2014 Rock Hall inductees. First, I'm ECSTATIC about Kiss FINALLY getting in! LONG OVERDUE and WELL DESERVED! Simultaneously, I'm very disappointed that Deep Purple were snubbed twice in a row! A GLARING OMISSION indeed! Sigh...bit I digress. Posted by V.F.T. on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 15:09pm |
Bill, I do think Phillip asked a question that I would also be interested in: What old time soul/R/B acts do you think don't make the cut (leaving aside the R/B equivalents of Rebecca Black & The Archies)? Posted by Paul in KY on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 15:36pm |
Oh, come on Philip, we all know that you're really Evangelist. ;) Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 16:39pm |
"Bill, I do think Phillip asked a question that I would also be interested in: What old time soul/R/B acts do you think don't make the cut (leaving aside the R/B equivalents of Rebecca Black & The Archies)?" Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 17:39pm |
Smokey deserves a second induction (like Curtis Mayfield got: with THE IMPRESSIONS and solo), but he shot himself in the foot by accepting a solo induction without the rest of the Miracles back in 1987. Had Bobby, Ron, Pete, Claudette, and Marv gone in with him back then , he would have almost surely gotten a second induction for his writing, producing, and status as Motown Vice President. But now, it probably won't happen: The RRHOF also screwed up his chances ...by not inducting him again with the Miracles last year. Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 17:51pm |
Ooops. I forgot about EDWIN STARR. I think HE deserves to get in also.He had a number of big hits, before, during, and after Motown ...and was actually BIGGER in Europe than in the US... probably the biggest Starr (pun intended) of England's "Northern Soul" scene. Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 18:02pm |
Rumor is that Yusuf Islam will join Kiss for a rousing rendition of their 1983 classic "Lick It Up". It's up in the air if he will be in make-up. Posted by Classic Rock on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 18:15pm |
Philip, I don't understand why you said that I was one of the few people on this site who wanted to see more soul and R&B artists in the Hall of Fame because I've never really voiced my opinion about the issue. Posted by Andrew on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 19:41pm |
I am a little late to the party here, but I thought I would throw in my 2 cents. Posted by BSLO on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 20:36pm |
My Predictions for the Class of 2015, if they induct 6 artist Posted by Kyle on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 21:56pm |
What interests me most about next year is having two potential first ballot inductees newly eligible in Green Day and Nine Inch Nails. Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 22:35pm |
I would add to that by saying that I fully expect Green Day to go in first ballot next year, but NIN is more of a question mark to me. Posted by DarinRG on Thursday, 12/19/2013 @ 23:11pm |
NIN should be first ballot inductees but I think they'll probably have at least 3. Posted by rockstar23 on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 05:20am |
Appreciate your answer, Bill. Thanks! Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 07:54am |
BSLO, interesting comments. Enjoyed reading them. Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 08:11am |
Jim Croce wasn't a one hit wonder, not even close. He charted 8 top 40 hits, including 5 top 10's and 2 #1's. Posted by Classic Rock on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 08:41am |
Jim's got a name (and more hits), so don't mess around with him! Posted by Jason Voigt on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 10:00am |
I didn't lterally mean that, classicrocker. I was writing a long post & I shortcutted pon that. He did put all his stuff out in around a 2 year period though. Big flash, then his death. Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 13:55pm |
Good one Jason. Don't shoot pool with Slim either! Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 13:58pm |
Perhaps one of the unexpected positves of inducting these older 70s artists along side the newer, rap/alternative artists is that by standing on stage with them and jamming and whatnot, the hall is forcing them to be a bit more musically open and liberal on the definition of "rock and roll", even if just for a night. I don't know if people like the Wilson sisters, Alex Lifeson and Daryl Hall are out and out rockists who think real music died after 1991, but I think they'll be nicer to broadening the idea of rock and roll once they realize that, yes, Public Enemy and Nirvana care just as much about "rawk" as they do. (As opposed to entering the same time as their peers, which basically turns into a bunch of yes men). Posted by Jim on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 15:28pm |
Paul in KY - It will be interesting to see what happens with Gram Parsons. After Cat Stevens' induction, I think I'm willing to expect the unexpected. He has been on the ballot before, so I wouldn't put it past the nominating committee to give him another shot. Posted by BSLO on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 17:14pm |
Perhaps one of the unexpected positves of inducting these older 70s artists along side the newer, rap/alternative artists is that by standing on stage with them and jamming and whatnot, the hall is forcing them to be a bit more musically open and liberal on the definition of "rock and roll", even if just for a night. I don't know if people like the Wilson sisters, Alex Lifeson and Daryl Hall are out and out rockists who think real music died after 1991, but I think they'll be nicer to broadening the idea of rock and roll once they realize that, yes, Public Enemy and Nirvana care just as much about "rawk" as they do. (As opposed to entering the same time as their peers, which basically turns into a bunch of yes men). Posted by Cheesecrop on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 18:20pm |
Bill G., thank you for your reply. I hope you expand beyond Motown as to where those limits might be, but that's a good approximation. Personally, I disagree with you about Tammi Terrell (her legacy too closely linked with Marvin Gaye even though she did have a respectable career as a solo-billing artist), solo Lionel (Dancing On The Ceiling is a classic, and All Night Long while not my fave has some solid R&B rhythms to it), and a little bit about DeBarge and Rare Earth... on the fence about both of them, but leaning more towards yes for both. I'm not familiar enough with the Stone City Band, but would be okay with Rick James solo. Posted by Philip on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 20:35pm |
Philip, I don't understand why you said that I was one of the few people on this site who wanted to see more soul and R&B artists in the Hall of Fame because I've never really voiced my opinion about the issue. Posted by Andrew on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 22:11pm |
Andrew, I guess I read into your posts a bit more than I should have. You're not really denying it, ,either. If I'm mistaken, I apologize. As for "what's a rockist?" Neckbeard is back. Read his posts and you'll get the picture. Put in oversimplified terms: if you think Aretha Franklin or James Brown shouldn't be in the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame because soul is not rock...rockist. Posted by Philip on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 23:30pm |
You don't even have to stop at Aretha and James. Rockists will generally find a reason that any predominantly black genre doesn't make the cut. Posted by DarinRG on Friday, 12/20/2013 @ 23:56pm |
Am I the only one here who finds the term "rockist" a bit silly? I don't deny that there are folks who feel that the RnRHOF should be predominantly rock and rollers, but the effort to create a derogatory "-ist" term for them is quite funny to me. Of all the -ists on the planet, rockists should be the least of our worries. LOL. Posted by Classic Rock on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 00:52am |
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought that the purpose of this site was to determine who DESERVES to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame....not who DOESN'T . Posted by Bill G on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 01:11am |
It probably should be RAWKists in order to get the point across easier. Posted by Casper on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:11am |
Crossley uses it a lot. Not sure if he coined it, but it's possible. And I do prefer the "rawkist" spelling as well. It fits the attitude of the disorder better. Posted by DarinRG on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:17am |
Kelefa Sanneh from The New York Times came up with the term... Posted by Sean on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:20am |
No, it appears reading his article "The Rap Against Rockism" that it was coined much earlier and he just popularized it. Posted by Sean on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:21am |
Since R&B was one of ...if not the most important PROGENITOR of what is today called Rock and Roll, excluding R&B artists from the Hall is ludicrous. Why should Black Artists be excluded from being honored for a genre which Blacks CREATED ?? Posted by Bill G on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:31am |
I think the induction of Cat Stevens proves pretty much that any singer-songwriter that ends up on the ballot will get in. Especially at this stage. There was a period in the 2000's when Gram Parsons, Cat Stevens, John Mellencamp, Lou Reed, and Randy Newman all got nominated but didn't get in. But that was at the time when the Hall was starting to get to the major 80's artists and punk rock artists (Michael Jackson, Prince, U2, Talking Heads, REM, The Police, Elvis Costello, etc.). So there just wasn't room for them. Posted by Donnie on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:35am |
Also, where is this info that many people in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame not liking Gram Parsons coming from? Posted by Donnie on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 02:39am |
Of the remaining singer-songwriters in contention, I believe these four have the best chance: Posted by rockstar23 on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 05:32am |
BSLO, good writeup on Darren's/My comments. Excellent point about Soundgarden not even being nominated yet. Certainly, I would think Green day would get a nom/induction prior to NIN (according to what I've seen the last several years). Posted by Paul in KY on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 10:46am |
Donnie, I've read a couple books about that era, not at home so I can't remember the title, but I read several disparaging things about him, quoting multiple people who are now in HOF. Posted by Paul in KY on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 10:57am |
"Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought that the purpose of this site was to determine who DESERVES to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame....not who DOESN'T "--Bill G. Posted by Philip on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 12:08pm |
"He had an arrogant personality. Gram Parsons was sure Gram Parsons was the greatest thing in music. Posted by Philip on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 12:12pm |
Wait, people are arguing party-loving egotists shouldn't be in the hall? Posted by GFW on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 12:46pm |
I am not a "rockist," I am a "progressive rock" enthusiast however, and I have been one for nearly 35 years. As such here is my list for 2015 nominees to the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 13:29pm |
Of course, I would not be upset if Jethro Tull, or King Crimson receives a nod also, although my more balanced class would consist of the following artists: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 13:38pm |
I am not a "rockist," I am a "progressive rock" enthusiast however, and I have been one for nearly 35 years. As such here is my list for 2015 nominees to the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame: Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 16:18pm |
http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_hall-of-fame-2014.html Posted by Roy on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 18:20pm |
I could honestly care less if Gram Parsons was an entitled, egomaniac, drug addict. He certainly wouldn't be the only person with those traits presently in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Posted by Donnie on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 19:47pm |
I'm right there with you, Donnie, on Gram Parsons. Posted by Andrew on Saturday, 12/21/2013 @ 20:32pm |
Well said, Donnie. Co-signed. Posted by DarinRG on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 00:15am |
***A Hall Voter's Definition or Rock and Roll*** Posted by Bill G on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 00:38am |
Exactly. I've kept my comments about Cat music-based, only noting that the hiatus caused by his conversion impacted his career...because he wasn't putting out any music at all, no capitalizing on his chance to continue and strengthen his musical legacy. And at the risk of being misinterpreted, I think any comment made slighting America or its policies would cause his stock to go up in the eyes of the powers-that-be, providing those comments were made either during the Ford, Reagan, or either of the Bush presidencies. Posted by Philip on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 00:43am |
http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/the_music_club/features/2013/music_club_2013/the_rock_hall_of_fame_and_the_billboard_hot_100_where_were_the_black_acts.html Posted by Bill G on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 01:05am |
Phillip, these were all people with big egos saying that. People who live/work all the time with those who have a very healthy id. Posted by Paul in KY on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 08:22am |
Donnie, understand you don't give a shit. I don't either. I'm trying to show you reasons (petty reasons, mostly) why Gram Parsons has never been inducted, despite being well known & a contemporary of many HOF members. Posted by Paul in KY on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 08:39am |
Donnie, understand you don't give a shit. I don't either. I'm trying to show you reasons (petty reasons, mostly) why Gram Parsons has never been inducted, despite being well known & a contemporary of many HOF members. Posted by Paul in KY on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 08:40am |
Andrew, the things I've read about Gram that people who knew him recounted (people who are in Hall) boil down to this: Posted by Paul in KY on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 08:45am |
Sorry I'm late for the party but I agree with some of you, I don't care with some artist's personnel lives, I only care about their work. Posted by John R.C. on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 14:08pm |
Was hoping Chic would get in so they can stop getting on the ballot. At least Kiss is finally in (and the annual classic rock inductee to boot). Posted by Anonymous on Sunday, 12/22/2013 @ 18:57pm |
I still feel that a special RRHOF "veterans committee" should be formed ...to make sure that deserving pre-80's R&B acts get proper representation for induction. As the median age of the Rock Hall voters gets younger, these artists won't have a prayer of getting in....and the backlog is far too big already. I submit that this committee should have the power to simply induct without nomination and voting ...like the 6 classic groups were voted in last year. The voters obviously won't vote them in....so don't even GIVE them the opportunity to reject them . Just put them in. Everybody knows they deserve to be there. Posted by Bill G on Monday, 12/23/2013 @ 14:20pm |
Not a bad idea at all, Bill. Baseball HOF has one for basically same reasons. Posted by Paul in KY on Monday, 12/23/2013 @ 14:56pm |
Bill - You probably already know this from the conversations at ToC, but I totally agree on the Veteran's Committee idea. Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 12/23/2013 @ 16:26pm |
Bill - You probably already know this from the conversations at ToC, but I totally agree on the Veteran's Committee idea. Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 12/23/2013 @ 16:28pm |
These are just some of the artists that I would like to see in the Hall within the next few years: Posted by Andrew on Monday, 12/23/2013 @ 19:57pm |
http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_hall-of-fame-2014.html Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 05:01am |
DIGITAL DREAM DOOR (cONTINUED) Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 05:03am |
Bill, I read that article too. I have a problem with it on a couple of levels. While the analysis may be good in parts, invoking nooses, the klan, segregation Alabama...it is not really appropriate in this context, makes the author sound a bit juvenile and not really understanding the context of history, and to bring that up in the context of a music hall of fame discussion is rather insulting to the people who lived through that era and those horrors. It reminds me of people who toss around words like "nazis" and Holocaust way too carelessly. Posted by dezmond on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 08:49am |
Dezmond, Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 10:15am |
Happy Holidays all. There's been a bit of backlash regarding this class, and I will agree that considering the breadth of the nominees this year, the final outcome was truly disappointing. However, one of the more criticized choices, Cat Stevens, is probably the one I happiest about, and here's a little diatribe explaining why Cat Stevens rightfully belongs in the hall and remains one of the more underappreciated artists of his era. Posted by Josh Fitz on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 12:34pm |
As a fan of Linda Ronstadt, I would like to say that I understand that she is not everyone's cup of tea. And it would be easier to hear from her detractors if their comments were not mean spirited. After reading the Digital Dream Door assessment of her induction my initial reaction is: I get their point. However, if you were to ask Ronstadt fans why they love her I believe most would tell you her hits were their least favorite of her songs. Over the years even Linda herself has said many of those selections were thrown onto albums as afterthoughts to try for radio play. Her albums were mostly crafted for full album listening. Many of her hits can be better appreciated in the context of listening to her full albums. It makes me wonder if the folks at DDD and others have really listened to her full recordings more than once or twice. That being said, although her Heatwave does not compare to Martha Reeves version, her Poor Poor Pitiful Me, Different Drum and Desperado are all arguably superior to the originals. I personally prefer her Back in the USA to Chuck Berry's version. DDD also says she was a pretty face with a pretty voice. Sorry, she has a great voice. One of the best and most beautiful voices to record American popular music. I think there are many who will agree. Posted by Richie on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 12:47pm |
(continued) And I also wonder how many of the Ronstadt detractors have actually heard her sing live. Posted by Richie on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 12:50pm |
Dezmond, Posted by Chris F. on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 13:12pm |
Josh, I've made my feelings about Cat Stevens known pretty well, so I'll stick to just facts on this rebuttal. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 13:49pm |
Ritchie, why would hearing Ronstadt live make a difference to this discussion? few people here dispute that she has a fantastic voice. But is that enough for the Hall of Fame? No. Posted by Dezmond on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 14:01pm |
Thanks for your reply, Dezmond. My comment regarding Linda's voice was made in response to the DDD statement that she had a pretty face with a pretty voice. The implication being that her voice was not remarkable but ordinary. Although not stated in my comment, it was also a response to other descriptions made lately regarding her voice such as "random, mediocre….", "shrill banshee" etc. Posted by Richie on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 14:31pm |
Dezmond, Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 14:37pm |
That whole bit about "Negro records" and the KKK was utterly ridiculous, couldn't take it seriously afterwards. Posted by GFW on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 15:21pm |
Thanks for your reply, Philip. I am sorry if you felt attacked by rabid Ronstadt supporters. I respectfully disagree with what you said about singles and radio airplay etc. While I certainly can understand why individuals may not have been drawn to Ronstadt's deeper album cuts if they did not care for the singles, I don't feel the same logic applies to committees charged with evaluating her HOF worthiness. I believe her entire output should be judged. I have not posted anything negative here regarding any other artist because I simply have not heard enough of them. Of course I am familiar with the radio hits of lots of these artists but I would never say someone should or should not be inducted into the HOF until I was very familiar with their entire catalogue. And as far as what record companies submit for radio airplay, I don't necessarily think the go with "the best", but what is "radio friendly". I am not an expert here but it seems likely that is the case. Posted by Richie on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 15:28pm |
Dezmond, Posted by Chris F. on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 17:13pm |
" I will say that of all the acts I have seen very few come close to touching the loyalty, and therefore trolling ability, of Patti LaBelle's. One toe out of line with them and it is destruction. Fanaticism is a dangerous thing." Posted by GFW on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 17:40pm |
Nothing more intimidating than GFW laying down the law. Posted by DarinRG on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 18:55pm |
ill 'av em lad Posted by GFW on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 19:10pm |
Call me crazy, but I think this is a very solid class. I think they are all worthy, and some of them long overdue. Sure, others are just as worthy but if Percy Sledge is in then how can I complain about any of these. Posted by Classic Rock on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 21:52pm |
ANSWER: Because Percy Sledge shouldn't be in . Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 23:20pm |
ANSWER: Because Percy Sledge shouldn't be in . Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 23:20pm |
Sorry. That wasn't supposed to go in twice. Posted by Bill G on Tuesday, 12/24/2013 @ 23:21pm |
I would trade Sledge for Brook Benton or anything Bill mentioned Posted by Jason Voigt on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 00:24am |
I like a lot of DDR's lists. I really do. but that assessment of the inductees was ignorant, and, quite frankly, racist. Posted by Paul K on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 02:26am |
Rant over with, this wasn't my ideal class. That would have been: Posted by Paul K on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 02:37am |
That would've been a better class. Now if you take that and replace Kiss and Yes with Paul Butterfield and Link Wray, you've got about the best class that this year's ballot could've produced. Posted by DarinRG on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 03:09am |
As I've said often, Linda Ronstadt has no business being inducted, period. We knew the fix was in the moment they nominated her, and she had friends in high places, but other than selling some records, and not in world shattering numbers, she did nothing to deserve it. By that standard every commercially successful artist deserves it. Really she was everything the R&RHF even in its stated criteria was supposed not to be about: uncreative, riskless, safe, middle of the road. And her non-existing legacy shows it. Her supporters piled up so much bs (first female rock superstar [LOL], country rock pioneer [LOL], etc.), that it was absurd. When an artist deserves an honor it is apparent. When they don't, spin like mad. The only consolation for a token induction is that we now have a strong candidate for the worst artist ever inducted. Now her fans can say she is in the R&RHF. But the ship sailed a long time ago. Posted by astrodog on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:15am |
Paul K, Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:16am |
To all those deteractors who do not like "progressive rock," bands: I say, "I Wish You Well!" Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:22am |
To all those detractors who do not like progressive rock: I say, "I Wish You Well!" Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:26am |
Astrodog, Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:32am |
I don't know if there was an "ideal class" for me. Other than KISS and Nirvana, I don't think there was an act that was in my top six for both objective merits and personal taste. So, with KISS and Nirvana both in, I could call it good enough (even though Cat Stevens ranked dead last in both lists for me). Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 10:42am |
Without Linda Ronstadt, there would probably be no Eagles. Posted by Jason Voigt on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 11:03am |
This is a great class. I've said it before and I'll say it again: I believe all the others on the ballot will eventually get inducted. Hopefully next year will be 'Heinz 57' year. By the way, I find it hard to believe Green Day will be eligible for next year. Even though their breakout year was 1994, its always easy to forget they released their first record in the 80s. Posted by Jason Voigt on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 11:06am |
Jason, Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 11:34am |
I think that the major complaint is that, while the Hall was once very fair and equitable about R&B artists getting inducted in it's early years, in recent years (since 2005 or so) it's been sort of of a "rockist's paradise" . Or, to quote Janet Jackson: "What have you done for me LATELY". Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 11:52am |
Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:15pm |
While Linda beats Dionne in the number of Grammy Awards won, Dionne beats Linda in the number of OVERALL CAREER AWARDS WON. Dionne also has more songs in the GRAMMY HALL OF FAME (Warwick-3, Ronstadt,0), and 2 songs in The R.I.A.A.'s "Songs Of The Century) vs. Ronstadt's 0 : Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:35pm |
Paul K, Posted by Chris F. on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:39pm |
Bill G., Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:42pm |
Dionne Warwick is one of the greatest female singers in American Pop Music History and another of my favorites. As the RRHOF has evolved into more of a Pop Music HOF, she definitely deserves to be enshrined along with Ronstadt. The problem is she has no association to traditional R&R music. Ronstadt actually recorded lots of R&R songs. I believe she should and will make it in someday. But really, at some point this institution needs to change its name to be more reflective of it's Pop leanings as of late. Posted by Richie on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:48pm |
I Love Sade (for more than just her music) . LOL. Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:49pm |
My personal list would be different than the Rock Hall's choices. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 12:57pm |
Of course, if the Rock Hall is following William Goodman's Fuse Snub List, which consists of the following artists, then either T. Rex, or Chicago could be next. His list had included the following artists, by the way: Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 13:09pm |
Or perhaps, The Electric Light Orchestra. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 15:21pm |
ABBA is indeed pristine pop, but with songs like "Waterloo", "So Long", and "Does Your Mother Know?" (which have some nice rock riffs in the) and "I Do, I Do, I Do, I Do, I Do" (has a nice Clarence "Frogman" Henry feel to it), ABBA does have some bona fide "rock 'n' roll" songs. Ronstadt definitely has the country-rock thing going. I'll stand by both selections. I've gone on enough about my distaste for both Dionne and Burt & Hal, so I'll forgo that again. Interesting list of awards and honors listed, though I do wonder about the prestige level of some of them (Kleenex American Hero Award?). But again, I'll fully admit that my opposition is based on personal taste and leave it at that. Sade is deserving, though I find them (they were a group first) kind of boring. Great rhythm lines, though. But I'd relent to that selection. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 15:55pm |
I knew I'd hear from you sooner or later. Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 16:30pm |
goddamn people it's christmas you gotta have something better to do than arguing on here Posted by GFW on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 16:58pm |
I'd rather see someone politely voicing their differences of opinion than you taking the Lord's name in vain on Christmas Day. Do you have any shame? Posted by Evangelist on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 17:17pm |
aw sweet, Evan my man, where you been? Posted by GFW on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 18:12pm |
"Any questions?"--Bill G. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 18:33pm |
Though, to be fair, I should give her credit for her chameleon-like versatility as a singer. Her B&D stuff sounds like typical B&D stuff (compared with Jackie DeShannon's "What The World Needs Now Is Love"); "Then Came You" sounds very much like a Spinners record, or anything produced by Bell. "Heartbreaker" definitely sounds like something the Bee Gees would have done. To be that flexible and adaptable is a credit to her merit. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 18:39pm |
Whatever. Posted by Bill G on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 19:57pm |
Philip, Posted by Chris F. on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 22:37pm |
On the topic of Dionne Warwick. Posted by Chris F. on Wednesday, 12/25/2013 @ 23:34pm |
You're absolutely RIGHT, Chris !! Dionne's musical background was firmly entrenched in R&B. Before her solo success, she was a renowned background vocalist on recordings of The Drifters, Ben E. King, Chuck Jackson, Dinah Washington, Ronnie "The Hawk" Hawkins, and Solomon Burke among many others. .She also had a strong gospel background. Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 03:03am |
Bill, personal opinions are just part of the game here. And it could just as easily be said that you're trying to color other people's opinions by posting yours about certain artists quite frequently too. It's part of what we do because we believe in/against certain artists being enshrined in the Hall Of Fame. And voters, when they have to pick only five from a list of fifteen, are probably going to be heavily jaded by their personal opinions and preferences too. Dionne's '70s stuff is better than her '60s, imo, because I think her '60s stuff comes off as trite fluff, but I've heard the same thing said about different eras of the Beatles and Elvis. I have a right to post my opinions just as surely as you do. I try more and more to be polite in expressing my opinions, but unless I actually agree with you completely, it just seems to ruffle your feathers. But I'm not going to stop, and I don't think you will either. If "unquestionable music excellence" is the standard, the she falls shy of the mark for me, whereas she flies over the bar for you. As you said, "Whatever." Posted by Philip on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 10:42am |
" Which is why "Walk On By" is something people look to as a ultimate track of Rock'N'Roll." Posted by GFW on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 11:05am |
Which is why "Walk On By" by Dionne is in The Grammy Hall of Fame . Posted by Bill G on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 11:29am |
Philip, Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 12:55pm |
IMO, Ms. Warwick is long overdue for enshirement. To me she was, at a miminum, what Linda Rondstat was trying to be. Again riffing off the recent enshrinement of Ms. Rondstat, at her peak she was a much bigger star in popular music than Ms. Rondstat. Posted by Paul in KY on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 14:28pm |
Long overdue for Ronstadt. Would be delighted to see Dionne in as well. But other gals like Carly, Carole King and Sade are vocal lightweights. Astrodogs criticism of Linda, give us a break - he is like a spurned lover, stalking and libeling her remarkable talent and influence pathetically on this board. We knew she would sail in once she got out of the nominating committee - because Linda was the voice, the heart and the center of the Southern California rock scene. Her rock cred is substantial and certifiable. If Keith and Mick, Chuck Berry, Smokey Robinson, Neil Young, Robert Plant among others cast their votes -who do you think would be first ? Linda, cause her musicianship is second to none and to hear her live was to be transported. She doesn't give a damn about the RRHF or her fans and fame has always seemed to be drag for her. In the end it is her voice. No one could sing like her - no one even tries. Posted by blaster on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 14:49pm |
Platinum studio albums: Posted by Classic Rock on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 18:52pm |
Blaster-Oh I think you name singers in popular music that were better than Ronstadt (e.g.-Streisand, Durham, Carpenter, Slick, Joplin, McCoo, Carey, Benatar, Dion, Houston, Warwick, Patie Santos, Summer). That's just off the top of my head. Posted by astrodog on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 18:57pm |
blaster, Posted by Chris F. on Thursday, 12/26/2013 @ 21:48pm |
"Platinum studio albums: Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 01:12am |
"Warwick has sold over 100 million albums worldwide" Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 02:07am |
Ronstadt charted 38 Billboard Hot 100 singles"- Wikipedia Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 02:09am |
Dionne Warwick - 12 Top 10 Hits in the Billboard Hot 100 Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 02:14am |
Dionne Warwick - 18 Top 20 Hits - Billboard Hot 100 Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 02:25am |
Classic Rock, Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 02:58am |
Bill G., not to throw more fuel on the fire, but that "second most charted" is three-quarters-true, and a little misleading. Only three-quarters-true, because she's tied for second: Connie Francis also has 56 Pop chart (including pre-"Hot 100") hits from 1957-1998, 35 Top 20 (all but two "Hot 100"), 21 Top 20 (only one pre-"Hot 100"), 16 Top Ten 10 (one pre-"Hot 100"), and 3 #1's (all Hot 100). I feel it's a little misleading and extremely disingenuous to not include Connie's pre-Hot 100 hits because it unfairly punishes her for having a career before Billboard retooled its methodology and renamed its chart. I personally also feel that caveats should be noted when saying "most charted", because the Hot 100 isn't the only game in town. In addition to Billboard's country & western, R&B, AC, etc. charts, there's also the pre-rock data that should be included for proper context, as well as the data from competitor publications like Cashbox (although Whitburn has only recently been compiling that data for easy access). Anyhow, I suppose the main reason I mention it is because Connie's well ahead of Dionne in my personal pecking order of Rock Hall snubs. Posted by Philip on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 11:39am |
Enig. That would be Rush of "today's Tom Soy" fame. The album stats are current RIAA certifications. Rush currently only has 2 multi-platinum studio albums per the RIAA, and that's a fact. They recently submitted several things to the RIAA so that may change. Posted by Classic Rock on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 11:39am |
Classic Rock, Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 11:43am |
Classic Rock, Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 11:49am |
"Anyhow, I suppose the main reason I mention it is because Connie's well ahead of Dionne in my personal pecking order of Rock Hall snubs. Anyhow, I suppose the main reason I mention it is because Connie's well ahead of Dionne in my personal pecking order of Rock Hall snubs." Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 12:19pm |
Bill G, there's one very important question regarding your reply that is make-or-break in this disussion: Posted by Philip on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 12:57pm |
"Streisand, Slick, Joplin, Carey, Dion, Houston and possibly Summer are always going to score high no matter how you slice it. They are better vocalists than Ronstadt..." Posted by astrodog on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 13:41pm |
Nice to see we're bringing up what really matters when talking about music. Posted by GFW on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 14:20pm |
Patti LaBelle HAS to come up when you're talking about awesome female singers.Her vocal power is nothing short of incredible. Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 14:43pm |
"Nice to see we're bringing up what really matters when talking about music. Posted by Philip on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 15:27pm |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsTQtGSIUgk Posted by Bill G on Friday, 12/27/2013 @ 19:30pm |
I am not a "rockist," I am a "progressive rock" enthusiast however, and I have been one for nearly 35 years. As such here is my list for 2015 nominees to the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame: Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 01/1/2014 @ 10:55am |
My nominees for 2015: Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 19:53pm |
The Zombies Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 19:54pm |
JJ Cale Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 19:58pm |
Molly Hatchet Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 20:00pm |
The Big Bopper Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 20:04pm |
Jackie Brenston and His Delta Cats Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 20:06pm |
Dick Dale and His Del Tones Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 20:10pm |
The enigmatic intro to Morning Has Broken was performed by Rick Wakeman, keyboardist for YES. But YES is not in the HoF. What a freaking joke. Posted by dkaplan on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 22:36pm |
The flute solo on Cat Stevens' "Katmandu" was played by another fellow inductee, Peter Gabriel Posted by Aaron O'Donnell on Saturday, 01/4/2014 @ 23:47pm |
I think SVZ should induct Peter Gabriel because Gabriel's song "Biko" about slain anti-apartheid activist Steve Biko was the catalyst for the "Sun City" project. Also I believe Nelson Mandela's passing prompted the induction of Peter Gabriel since "Biko" was the first song to make people aware of the wrongfulness of apartheid. The RRHOF induction ceremony will take place on April 10, 2014. seventeen days before the twentieth anniversary of the banishment of apartheid from South Africa Posted by Aaron O'Donnell on Sunday, 01/5/2014 @ 21:26pm |
SVZ is going in with the E Street Band; he won't be presenting for anyone. Posted by Philip on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 00:44am |
PRESENTER PREDICTIONS: Posted by Roy on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 08:17am |
2014 PRESENTER PREDICTIONS: Posted by Roy on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 08:22am |
2014 PRESENTER PREDICTIONS: Posted by Roy on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 09:46am |
Roy, Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 17:39pm |
2014 PRESENTER PREDICTIONS: Posted by Roy on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 22:27pm |
Here are my predictions for the 2014 Presenters: Posted by Andrew on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 22:35pm |
Roy, Posted by Roy on Monday, 01/6/2014 @ 22:44pm |
My presenter predictions.... Posted by Donnie on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 07:22am |
I am sorry, but I have difficulty accepting this particular class of inductees, other than Hall & Oates and Peter Gabriel and perhaps Nirvana, I find this class to be much less interesting than last year's stellar cast. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 13:00pm |
I suppose that I can understand why Linda Ronstadt was inducted also. After all, Rolling Stone Magazine did love her back in the 1970's. But Cat Stevens induction does not make a great deal of sense, unless of course, he had remained Cat Stevens, or Stephen Georgiou, perhaps. But no, as we are all too well aware, he became Yusuf Islam and he subscribes to a religion that still treats women abhorrently. He may have made many charitable donations and started schools in the United Kingdom, but those are still Islamic schools. A better choice, in my honest opinion would have been for him to have donated money to the British school system, instead. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 13:16pm |
I suppose that I can understand why Linda Ronstadt was inducted also. After all, Rolling Stone Magazine did love her back in the 1970's. But Cat Stevens induction does not make a great deal of sense, unless of course, he had remained Cat Stevens, or Steven Georgiou, perhaps. But no, as we are all Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 14:00pm |
"I am sorry, but I have difficulty accepting this particular class of inductees,"--Enigmaticus Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 15:25pm |
*Andrew Loog Oldham, not Andre. Made him more continental than I should have. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 15:28pm |
Well stated Philip. Posted by Donnie on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 16:57pm |
Leadbelly was a goddamn killer and you say Cat shouldn't be in cos he's a muslim? Posted by GFW on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 17:28pm |
I made an error in my post. Posted by Donnie on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 18:18pm |
This may be all the cold medication talking, but I bro-love you so much right now Donnie (and GFW). Weirdly enough, it's been this cold and accompanying cabin fever that has made me crotchety to lash out when irked like I did initially there. I hope I ditch this cold in time for... hayfever season. Oh joy. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 18:30pm |
Well done, Donnie and Philip, Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 01/7/2014 @ 22:31pm |
Did someone mention cold medicine? That's quite ironic, because I have been very ill for the past 5 days. Get well soon, Philip. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 01/8/2014 @ 07:43am |
Here Is whom I infer will be presenting the newly crowned inductees for the RRHOF Class of 2014. I will also seek to explain why these individuals are likely to present the new inductees. Posted by Lax31 on Sunday, 01/12/2014 @ 22:22pm |
1. Nirvana - What about maybe Buzz and Dale Crover of the Melvins? I agree Eddie Vedder would be good, but Dale drummed with Nirvana and Buzz joined Krist and Dave for "Melvana" once. Posted by JHerndon on Tuesday, 01/14/2014 @ 19:23pm |
FYI, the inductees have been announced for over a month now, and I was still able to vote in the poll just now. Any reason it's still up and running? Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 01/15/2014 @ 16:35pm |
Hopefully the inductions of Peter Gabriel and Hall & Oates will bode well for the nomination and induction of Duran Duran in the near future. Posted by Enigmaticus on Saturday, 02/8/2014 @ 11:55am |
http://songhall.org/news/entry/songwriters_hall_of_fame_announces_2014_inductees Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 02/11/2014 @ 18:35pm |
No Chic and no Cat Stevens in the Songwriters Hall of Fame this year! Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 02/11/2014 @ 18:37pm |
Cat Stevens can stay out of the Songwriters Hall Of Fame. Really still feel he is a third-rate singer/songwriter. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 02/11/2014 @ 21:18pm |
FRL, the Hall has put up some information about ceremony in their website, most of which were recently announced by you but the Hall haven't publicly announced them yet. It also includes the air date for HBO to brodcast the ceremony at the bottom of the page. Posted by John R.C. on Wednesday, 02/19/2014 @ 21:58pm |
So what are everyone's opinions about the whole Kiss debate? From one perspective, I do believe that it's important to induct only the members that have made the *most* impact/hold the most significance to the history of the band (i.e. just inducting Simmons/Stanley/Frehley/Criss), however I also see Simmons and Stanley's point of wanting to induct their other members, especially if someone like Robert Trujillo or Josh Klinghoffer are hall of famers, (meanwhile Ronnie James Dio for Black Sabbath is not or Steve Mackay for The Stooges are not.) Posted by Steve Z on Tuesday, 02/25/2014 @ 10:58am |
Steve, I think it has to be looked at on a case by case basis. Posted by Paul in KY on Tuesday, 02/25/2014 @ 15:14pm |
"Steve, I think it has to be looked at on a case by case basis." Posted by Steve Z on Wednesday, 02/26/2014 @ 20:49pm |
You've got to love the irony that they priced these tickets way above what the average fan could afford and rented out a huge venue in order to take advantage of the Kiss Army that they'e neglected for yeears...now KISS isn't playing and we're supposed to believe that all those tickets actually sold out? And is anybody really going to pay a scalper (i.e. Ticketmaster's sites where they put up a bunch of tickets at a highr price) even MORE than those already exorbitant costs? Posted by Casper on Saturday, 03/1/2014 @ 18:22pm |
I guess Ticketmaster's logic is that there's enough hardcore Kiss and Nirvana fiends to make these tickets worth reselling at an even higher premium...probably should have put more of them on sale in order to effectively gauge demand. Posted by Casper on Saturday, 03/1/2014 @ 18:28pm |
Also, I'm sorry, but nobody should be paying that much money to attend this ceremony. It irks me that some KISS head will be willing to pay $500 to see these guys collect an award and not even perform and then sit through hours of speeches and concerts they could give a shit about. The same goes for anybody else attending because they're a super fan of one act, especially since most of them won't even be performing. Posted by Casper on Saturday, 03/1/2014 @ 18:29pm |
Honestly, if you're into Hall and Oates or whatever, just go see them play a full show. You'll get about eight times the songs that you would when they rush through a truncated three track set at the ceremony and the audience won't be filled with metal heads and younger grunge fans that could care less. Posted by Casper on Saturday, 03/1/2014 @ 18:31pm |
Who I hope for inducts each act: Posted by Gassman on Thursday, 03/6/2014 @ 17:04pm |
Hello there! Posted by Lax31 on Saturday, 03/15/2014 @ 21:18pm |
I do think Simmons/Stanley are being dumb by refusing to play with Frehley/Criss, but like all things KISS post-1978, there is some salad in that big plate of shit. Posted by Jim on Saturday, 03/15/2014 @ 22:26pm |
Y'know Jim, at this point, I even wonder if the Hall actually wanted them to perform. We know that KISS isn't exactly loved by the powers-that-be, and it's taken forever to get them inducted. I can't help but wonder if the Hall hasn't been acting intentionally like this to minimize the impact of KISS during the actual ceremony. I mean, there's no way they could have expected the KISS army and band themselves to react any differently to the news that Chad Channing was going to be included with Nirvana. Unfortunately, it's made me want to see KISS onstage at Barclay's even less now. You just KNOW that Paul and Gene's combined 8 minutes are going to be a rant about Hall hypocrisy and Gene's horrendously myopic definition of Rock And Roll. Let's just hope Ace and Peter can talk quickly enough to get all the thank-yous in. Posted by Philip on Sunday, 03/16/2014 @ 12:16pm |
That may be true Phillip, although that would essentially be shooting themselves in the foot business-wise, mainly because KISS are the only real attraction of this class, and I think the hall was banking on that. Posted by Jim on Monday, 03/17/2014 @ 13:53pm |
Well, not even two days have gone by and we now learn that Chad Channing will not be included as an officially inducted band member with Nirvana. The RRHOF are not winning any friends with these maneuvers. It does make me wonder, though, if the Board of Directors are entirely against Every Performer inductee this year. We do know the other categories are decided upon by their respective subcommittees, and not the official fan and industry ballots. So, why would Dave Marsh, Jon Landau and co. have any problems with the six Performers inductees? Posted by Lax31 on Monday, 03/17/2014 @ 20:22pm |
I just don't see a lot of enthusiasm in general. Year after year rock is sinking into irrelevance. Popular culture has moved on. And the R&RHF hasn't done itself any favors with a view of rock embedded in the mid 90s. The staleness of rock music is reflected in the R&RHF's uncreative choices. Posted by astrodog on Tuesday, 03/18/2014 @ 01:20am |
I just don't see a lot of enthusiasm in general. Year after year rock is sinking into irrelevance. Popular culture has moved on. And the R&RHF hasn't done itself any favors with a view of rock embedded in the mid 90s. The staleness of rock music is reflected in the R&RHF's uncreative choices. Posted by astrodog on Tuesday, 03/18/2014 @ 01:21am |
I'm going to the induction ceremony! The tickets were too cheap to pass up and I know that they will still have an awesome lineup of performers. If my reception is good enough in the building, I will be live tweeting during the event. Very excited! Posted by Gassman on Friday, 03/28/2014 @ 12:47pm |
Hopeful presenters:* Posted by Philip on Friday, 03/28/2014 @ 14:47pm |
http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/bruce-springsteen-michael-stipe-will-appear-at-rock-hall-induction-20140401 Posted by John R.C. on Tuesday, 04/1/2014 @ 01:05am |
https://rockhall.com/blog/post/2014-rock-hall-induction-ceremony-special-guests/ Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 04/1/2014 @ 07:47am |
April has arrived! Posted by Roy on Tuesday, 04/1/2014 @ 07:49am |
I can't help but appreciate the near irony of Tom Morello inducting KISS: the guitarist of a band whose very name is indicative of their anti-corporate, anti-paradigm attitude and approach inducting a band who'd sell out what few ideals they have for a Klondike bar. Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 04/1/2014 @ 20:36pm |
I'm right there laughing with you Philip. I was really hoping for Lady Gaga, who would've been a perfect fit in most every way. Posted by DarinRG on Tuesday, 04/1/2014 @ 20:39pm |
This is from a piece on Cracked.com, an article called "The Five Worst Songs In The History Of Rock Music." This paragraph is talking about Nickelback and the song, "Worthy To Say." But as I read it, I thought that this could also apply quite aptly to KISS and "Rock And Roll All Nite." And once again, I'll remind you all... all this and I still supported and still think KISS is worthy of induction. Here's what was written. Posted by Philip on Wednesday, 04/2/2014 @ 01:20am |
They still have not posted the complete bios of this year's inductees on the Rock Hall website, neither which band members are being inducted. Yes I know we know. Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 04/9/2014 @ 22:10pm |
The 2014 Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame Order of Inductions: Posted by Roy on Thursday, 04/10/2014 @ 22:43pm |
The 2014 Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame Order of Inductions: Posted by Roy on Thursday, 04/10/2014 @ 22:43pm |
http://www.gettyimages.ca/Search/Search.aspx?contractUrl=2&language=en-GB&family=editorial&assetType=image&p=2014+Rock+and+Roll+Hall+of+Fame Posted by Roy on Thursday, 04/10/2014 @ 23:02pm |
http://www.wireimage.com/search/#events?q=2014%20Rock%20and%20Roll%20Hall%20of%20Fame&s=1 Posted by Roy on Thursday, 04/10/2014 @ 23:03pm |
Hmmm, St. Vincent and Nirvana. That's a level of awesome that I never anticipated. Posted by DarinRG on Friday, 04/11/2014 @ 00:50am |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=upnncbQtxjg Posted by Roy on Friday, 04/11/2014 @ 07:12am |
The Rock Hall has not posted the full bios of this year's inductees yet on their website. I'll have to email them. Posted by Roy on Friday, 04/11/2014 @ 22:31pm |
http://www.rbhalloffame.com Posted by Roy on Friday, 04/18/2014 @ 10:23am |
https://rockhall.com/inductees/ Posted by Roy on Saturday, 04/19/2014 @ 07:20am |
Maybe they are waiting until after the ceremony is televised on HBO to complete the bios. Posted by Roy on Monday, 04/21/2014 @ 22:54pm |
Is it too nearly to speculate on the nominees for the 2015 class, yet? Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 04/28/2014 @ 09:35am |
I am sorry, I had meant to say, is it too early to start the discussion and speculate on whom the nominees will be for next year? Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 04/28/2014 @ 09:51am |
Well, Enigmaticus, the new entry on my blog, rockhallmonitors, actually starts thinking about that very thing. Posted by Philip on Monday, 04/28/2014 @ 23:38pm |
These are the artists whom I would like to see nominated for the rrhof induction in 2015 Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 05/4/2014 @ 19:33pm |
And as songwriter inductee, Bernie Taupin. Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 05/4/2014 @ 19:39pm |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9DT47h6HB0 Posted by Roy on Sunday, 05/4/2014 @ 23:28pm |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9DT47h6HB0 Posted by Roy on Monday, 05/5/2014 @ 05:59am |
Here's my list of 2015 Rock N Roll Hall of Fame nominees Posted by KING on Saturday, 05/17/2014 @ 20:20pm |
I had forgotten that there might be a push to induct Lou Reed as a solo artist, as well. What about Steve Winwood? I had almost forgotten about inducting him as a solo artist, also. With the exceptions of N.W.A. and Joan Jett, I like your list of nominees, KING. Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 05/18/2014 @ 14:37pm |
Thanks Enigmaticus!!! Like to see Duran Duran & Def Leppard get inducted in 2015. Both are deserving. I'm surprised Janet Jackson & Whitney Houston haven't had greater push to induction. Posted by KING on Sunday, 05/18/2014 @ 17:04pm |
KING wrote: Posted by Marissa on Monday, 05/19/2014 @ 12:07pm |
With Black Sabbath,KISS,Rush,Heart & Hall & Oates being inducted in recent years, it's doing a good job the RRHOF Committee of inducting worthy acts. Most of the giants & Legends have been inducted AC/DC, The Beatles, Bob Dylan,Bruce,Led zZeppelin,Prince,Madonna,U2 etc. Posted by KING on Tuesday, 05/20/2014 @ 18:00pm |
With Black Sabbath,KISS,Rush,Heart & Hall & Oates being inducted in recent years, it's doing a good job the RRHOF Committee of inducting worthy acts. Most of the giants & Legends have been inducted AC/DC, The Beatles, Bob Dylan,Bruce,Led zZeppelin,Prince,Madonna,U2 etc. Posted by KING on Tuesday, 05/20/2014 @ 18:12pm |
KING, Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 05/22/2014 @ 08:41am |
Regarding Tom Lane's Blog posting. Always enjoy reading your blog but I was at the RRHOF show and although the TV show was good and editing was probably necessary the one thing that was not captured (and probably could never be) was the amazing sonic experience of the live show. Cat Stevens' voice and singing at the live show must have turned some Nirvana fans into instant Stevens fans. He sounded that good live! During the Ronstadt tribute and especially the Nirvana performance I was absolutely blown away by the Barclay center acoustics. Both me and my friend who attended the live show and watched it on HBO last night agree that the sonic hangover we experienced after the April 10th show was not to be had today. The live show was fantastic. The only things missing were a KISS performance and Ronstadt's voice. Posted by Richie on Sunday, 06/1/2014 @ 09:38am |
You mean, I had missed seeing the godfather of "progressive rock" for this? Unfortunately, I had been unable to convince anyone else (colleagues, or associates) to accompany me to the Justin Hayward concert last night, so instead of purchasing tickets and attending, I had watched the 2014 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction ceremony last night. Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 06/1/2014 @ 12:52pm |
RnRHoF possibilities/picks for 2015: Posted by danny on Sunday, 06/1/2014 @ 17:23pm |
You can't count Chicago as a snub because they are being blackballed by Jann Wenner. They are way past the point of induction by now, no chance they will ever get inducted as long as Wenner runs the show at the Hall. Posted by Pete on Monday, 06/2/2014 @ 02:25am |
Prediction for 2015 ballot: Posted by Classic Rock on Wednesday, 06/4/2014 @ 21:13pm |
https://www.rockhall.com/inductees/ Posted by Roy on Wednesday, 06/4/2014 @ 22:52pm |
These are the artists whom I would like to see nominated for the rrhof induction in 2015 Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 06/6/2014 @ 09:47am |
I think that these artists would create a great Rock & Roll Hall Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/12/2014 @ 09:45am |
Let's rethink that order, by incorporating Yes and Deep Purple into the mix: Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/12/2014 @ 10:00am |
If Chicago were to be inducted, they would probably want to take advantage of a reunion with Peter Cetera. His replacement in the band, Jason Scheff, is a true gentleman, and would be happy to just play bass in the background and let Cetera sing the tenor parts. Posted by PopeCharming on Thursday, 06/12/2014 @ 10:35am |
I could not agree more, Popecharming. If Chicago does get on the ballot, their reunion with Peter Cetera would be an absolute must. Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 09:07am |
I could not agree more, Popecharming. If Chicago does get on the ballot, their reunion with Peter Cetera would be an absolute must. Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 09:29am |
What I would like to see the 2015 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction ceremony look like: Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 09:33am |
Or, is that too much star power for one event? How about Elton John inducting his co-writer Bernie Taupin in the songwriter category? Inducting Todd Rundgren and Nile Rodgers as producers? Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 09:39am |
Oh what the heck, let's add Chicago and E.L.O. and Bernie Taupin to the mix. Then, let's revise the songs themselves: Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 10:20am |
So I have heard that the 2014 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame induction ceremony wasn't that great. I wonder how well a 6 hr. Ceremony would go over? Posted by Enigmaticus on Thursday, 06/19/2014 @ 14:15pm |
It's almost September! Posted by Roy on Friday, 06/20/2014 @ 07:39am |
Yes Roy, it is almost September; depending on the definition of almost. You see, it is also almost July, and later it will be almost August. Thus it is almost correct to note that it is almost September. Posted by Lax31 on Sunday, 06/22/2014 @ 21:17pm |
Green Day and NIN can wait for another year or two, GD is not really that big in the 90s compared to Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Radiohead even Oasis, they became huge when these bands I mentioned were no longer active after year 2000 . Posted by chuva on Sunday, 06/22/2014 @ 23:22pm |
Here are my early predictions: Posted by Nick on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 01:08am |
Nick, those are great lists of nominees, but how the heck did you arrive at such an abysmal class from that list and where did N.W.A. come from? I think that if Duran Duran shows up on the nomination list, they would be immediate inductees. Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 04:32am |
Sorry Lax31, you did not include Deep Purple on your list. I had meant to say that from your list, I could only support Green Day and Eurythmics, instead. ;-) Posted by Eurythmics on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 05:00am |
Nick - Not a bad prediction at all. Ignore the delusional Prog slobberers Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 05:31am |
*slobberer - singular, my mistake. I respect most of the Prog fans on this site. Just not the one who thinks that Duran Duran is a prog band. Posted by DarinRG on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 05:38am |
there's a huge backlog of nominees, this is the right time for previous nominees to be nominated and inducted. Posted by chuva on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:07am |
Since some people are doing this, I think I can post my predictions (might varied to change): Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:10am |
Also, I'm with DarinRG, I really like Nick's predictions. Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:13am |
Sorry, change "Potential 7th slot" to "Wild Cards" since my prediction on who i think will be inducted has 7 artists (8 if you count the Bon Jovi/Purple as two inductees). Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:18am |
Sorry, change "Potential 7th slot" to "Wild Cards" since my prediction on who i think will be inducted has 7 artists (8 if you count the Bon Jovi/Deep Purple thing as two inductees). Posted by John R.C. on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:18am |
I'll probably be changing this list in the coming months, but my early nominees list is as follows: Posted by SotN on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 06:46am |
*slobberer - singular, my mistake. I respect most of the Prog fans on this site. Just not the one who thinks that Duran Duran is a prog band. Posted by Enigmaticus on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 10:20am |
Duran Duran is not a prog band. I love prog. And I love Duran Duran. But they are not related. Posted by Dezmond on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 10:52am |
I think, SotN, that you are very close to the mark. Here's my predictions, which overlap yours to a great degree. Posted by PopeCharming on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 10:54am |
And that should be "intimated", not "intimidated". Peter Cetera and Chicago might be the least intimidating people this side of Air Supply. Posted by PopeCharming on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 10:58am |
Thank you DarinRG and John R.C. for supporting my predictions for the 2015 class. It is only late June, so this is simply my early predictions and that is a long time away from September. As we all know, it is VERY difficult trying to figure out how the nominating committee will root for in a given year. Enigmaticus seems to have some sort of lovefest when it comes to Duran Duran because it seems like every post on the forums here has something to do with them. Yes, Enigmaticus I support Duran Duran going into the Rock Hall soon, but I'm not going to lose sleep if they don't (unlike you apparently). A problem I am realizing with many posters here is that their prediction lists are too one-sided; remember, the Rock Hall nominees have to be diverse musically (Rock, Pop, Rap, Soul, etc). Picking all Prog Rock and Alternative groups for potential nominees will never happen and that is something to keep in mind when creating such lists. Posted by Nick on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 14:48pm |
"Nick, those are great lists of nominees, but how the heck did you arrive at such an abysmal class from that list and where did N.W.A. come from?"--Enigmaticus Posted by Philip on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 20:10pm |
Since when was this last induction a debacle. Yes the KISS issue was annoying, but the rest of the induction was incredible. Posted by Gassman on Monday, 06/23/2014 @ 20:49pm |
1. Green Day Posted by Cheesecrop on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 06:55am |
BTW, that "1005" should read "100%". Posted by Cheesecrop on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 06:59am |
SotN and PopeCharming, your nominees lists are outstanding. By the way, so is Nick's. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 08:24am |
I still really like this idea for the 2015 ceremony, I think that it covers most of the bases: Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 08:46am |
I really like Cheesecrop's inductee list as well. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 09:08am |
I really like Cheesecrop's inductee list as well. Posted by Enigmaticus on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 09:37am |
Enigmaticus: Posted by Tom H. on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 11:02am |
Enig, Green Day would get 4 songs, as a 1st time inductee. IMO, those would be: Posted by Paul in KY on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 14:09pm |
Now that I'm starting to think about it, I am not sure if Nine Inch Nails will be be first-ballot Hall of Famers because the 2015 nominees list looks like it can be quite stacked (like the 2013 and 2014 nomination lists). I think Nine Inch Nails will definitely appear on the 2015 ballot (and in my opinion they would easily be first-ballot Hall of Famers), but they might be a tough sell with Green Day also appearing for the first time as well. Realistically, Nine Inch Nails will probably get in on their 2nd or 3rd try. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 14:39pm |
Sorry, I misspelled Joan Jett's name at the end of my post. Posted by Nick on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 15:18pm |
One thing i noticed about subcatergories is that they go in a three year roatation. Posted by John R.C. on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 16:53pm |
"Now, as far as my Duran Duran obsession is concerned; simply put, I want one of my best friend's favorite bands to get in. The way that I see it, various members on the nomination committee have been subtly supporting this for Posted by Philip on Tuesday, 06/24/2014 @ 20:38pm |
Thank you Tom H. The reason why I had only chosen two songs by Yes is due to their length. Personally, I would like to see "Classic Yes" perform 'Awaken,' but I know that is not likely to occur. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 00:36am |
"Now, as far as my Duran Duran obsession is concerned; simply put, I want one of my best friend's favorite bands to get in. The way that I see it, various members on the nomination committee have been subtly supporting this for Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 03:50am |
Thank you, Nick. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 08:23am |
As far as these lists are concerned: I think that it ultimately comes down to what resonates with you, personally. I had found out a long time ago, that "progressive rock" music had appealed to me personally, in a way that neither "heavy metal, nor punk rock ever could. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 09:22am |
As far as these lists are concerned: I think that it ultimately comes down to what resonates with you, personally. I had found out a long time ago, that "progressive rock" music had appealed to me personally, in a way that neither "heavy metal, nor punk rock ever could. Posted by Enigmaticus on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 09:27am |
** Here's MY Dream Ballot for 2015:** Posted by Bill G. on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 11:48am |
That would be a Hell of a ballot, Bill! Posted by Paul in KY on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 13:41pm |
...It sure WOULD, Paul !! Posted by Bill G. on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 13:56pm |
Bill G. re The Wailers Posted by Telarock on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 14:15pm |
This is true, Telarock. Posted by Bill G. on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 16:31pm |
Harry Womack Posted by Bill G. on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 16:39pm |
"Now, as to why DarinRG, does not like, nor respect me.." Posted by DarinRG on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 17:28pm |
"If they could do it to the E Street Band, then I think the Belmonts, Wailers and the Silver Bullet Band should be next. Posted by Steve Z on Wednesday, 06/25/2014 @ 23:55pm |
and Joe Long for The FOUR SEASONS and Alonzo Tucker for THE MIDNIGHTERS . Posted by Bill G. on Thursday, 06/26/2014 @ 00:36am |
I know this is a long shot in terms of inductions, but I'm really rooting for Mary Wells becoming a Rock Hall inductee soon. She was proclaimed "the queen of Motown" and sung one of the music company's most famous songs "My Guy" (1964). She has been nominated twice, but those nominations occurred in 1986 and 1987 (the first 2 years the Rock Hall began inducting artists and non-performers). She deserves a spot in the Rock Hall (the only other Motown act that should only be considered is The Marvelettes who was nominated last year), but her chances don't look too well at this point. Most people only know her because of "My Guy" and left Motown at the peak of her fame that didn't capture the same success. She seems to be forgotten by the nominating committee through the years which is a shame. Posted by Nick on Saturday, 06/28/2014 @ 18:36pm |
http://rockhall.com/inductees/ Posted by Roy on Saturday, 07/5/2014 @ 21:00pm |
So since you guys have been posting your dream ballots, I thought I'd postulate a new mental exercise. Since we're pretty much expecting that either Green Day or Nine Inch Nails is a shoo-in for next year, if the rest of the inductees were repeat nominees, what would your dream class of 2015 look like. Again it must be: Posted by Philip on Thursday, 07/17/2014 @ 22:23pm |
Under those circumstances, my non-ideal dream class would look like this: Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 04:36am |
Or better yet, this one instead: Posted by Enigmaticus on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 04:39am |
Phillip, Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 07:29am |
Paul, I don't mean to trample on your dream ballot, but the Doobie Brothers and ELO were never formally nominated. Posted by PopeCharming on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 07:57am |
Dream Ballot (under Philip's guidelines): Posted by Gassman on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 08:47am |
Thank you PopeCharming for correcting me. I didn't read close enough, it appears. In that case: Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 12:26pm |
Six nominees in a dream ballot, all of which are previous nominees with Green Day and/or NIN as an exception? Hmm: Posted by SotN on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 12:54pm |
By the way, if allowed a slot for an Early Influence past nominee, I'd pick the "5" Royales. Posted by SotN on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 13:00pm |
PopeCharming, Posted by Philip on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 22:45pm |
In that case, Philip, Chic would be my sixth choice (partly because I think they are the most important disco group not in, and partly to put an end to them getting nominated every single year.) Posted by PopeCharming on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 23:09pm |
My dream ballot with these stipulations Posted by Tom H. on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 23:15pm |
Philip: I'm not a fan of that stipulation myself (and was relieved that they didn't pull it this year with Link Wray), and if I want to avoid it, I'm more than willing to pull The Zombies from my ballot for them. No offense to the Zombies, love them like crazy, but my ballot was composed primarily of trailblazers who've yet to get their just due. Posted by SotN on Friday, 07/18/2014 @ 23:44pm |
Pope, I know how you feel. I almost put Kraftwerk on my list just to get that elephant out of the room, too, but I didn't go that route. I put the five that are probably the highest combined score between how I rank them by merit, and how i rank them by personal taste. Posted by Philip on Saturday, 07/19/2014 @ 00:23am |
Philip: Not a problem. Posted by SotN on Sunday, 07/20/2014 @ 16:46pm |
Going by Philip's stipulations with Green Day/Nine Inch Nails + 5 past nominees, here would be my ballot.... Posted by Donnie on Sunday, 07/20/2014 @ 19:15pm |
SotN, a lot of us also support Sister Rosetta Tharpe. Definitely a big one. The Ravens are a strong favorite too, though with awesome jams like Bye Bye Baby Blues and Write Me A Letter, might fit better into Performer than EI. Fats Waller is a seminal blues figure who's deserving, and I would say the Mills Brothers are much like Louis Jordan, who used their popularity with White audiences to seriously advance Black music. So any of those four would be serious cred for the Hall if they were inducted this coming round. Posted by Philip on Sunday, 07/20/2014 @ 20:22pm |
From the woman in my life: Posted by Philip on Sunday, 07/20/2014 @ 20:41pm |
My predictions for he 2015 rock hall nominations: Posted by Nick on Monday, 07/21/2014 @ 18:36pm |
Here is my list for the 2015 nominees: Posted by Andrew on Monday, 07/21/2014 @ 19:38pm |
So, beings we don't have a 2015 Nominees page up yet, I figured this section was the best one to bring this up. Posted by Donnie on Friday, 07/25/2014 @ 07:41am |
Donnie, it wouldn't flabbergast me if he was nominated. Still would consider him a longshot to be nominated at this time, though. Posted by Paul in KY on Friday, 07/25/2014 @ 07:53am |
Copy and paste if you think that Kate Bush should be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Spread Kate. The very first female singer-songwriter to do everything on her own. A pioneer of art rock, pop and sampling. Posted by Lipsticky on Sunday, 08/10/2014 @ 21:24pm |
Lipsticky, Posted by Enigmaticus on Sunday, 08/10/2014 @ 22:31pm |
This should've been it: Posted by Michael on Saturday, 10/13/2018 @ 18:08pm |
This site is not affiliated in any way with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum or the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation.