Eligible since: 1994 (The 1995 Induction Ceremony)
Previously Considered? No what's this?
Melanie @ Wikipedia
Comments22 comments so far (post your own)
That's an easy question...YES!!!
Posted by Bill Herrick on Saturday, 07.28.07 @ 10:37am
Who the Hell did she influence???
Posted by Joe-Skee on Saturday, 07.28.07 @ 11:15am
Before Melanie, there was Joan Baez and Leslie Gore and no one else, no women singers who wrote their own music. Suddenly there was Joni Mitchell and Judy Collins and Carly Simon and Roberta Flack and a host of female singer-songwriters. Even Carole King didn't haave much success as a singer until Melanie broke through.
Posted by MikeTheBear on Saturday, 07.28.07 @ 12:09pm
This is a tough one. Certainly, for a brief time, Melanie made her mark. I think she is one of the best songwriters of any generation. However, her image, will be a negative factor. She was viewed by serious critics as nothing more than " fluff". A dated artist whose date has passed. But, if you examine her songs on their own merit; she deserves to be in the hall of fame. But, I doubt if she will. The critics don't like her; business insiders dislike her, but hey, you never know. I think she should be considered a serious contender, but who am I?
Posted by Keith on Wednesday, 08.1.07 @ 21:11pm
Melanie deserves this honor for being one of the founders of the flower power movement as well as her deep spiritual belief in peace and love which reflects so much in her high energy voice and music she has given to us her entire life of performing.
Posted by mary jane nolen on Thursday, 08.2.07 @ 16:06pm
Posted by Pablo on Thursday, 08.16.07 @ 12:46pm
Posted by Pablo on Friday, 08.17.07 @ 15:39pm
When you view the list of signatories on the "Induct Melanie" petition, you will see the HUGE influence she has had throughout the entire WORLD.
Posted by Bill Herrick on Thursday, 01.3.08 @ 18:53pm
In her heyday Melanie's image was not one serious rock critics or the rock world wanted to be associated with. She was seriously misunderstood. Beneath the hippy image was a brilliant songwriter. In the 80s and 90s she struggled with a number of come backs. All failures. Not because she lacked the talent because she didn't, it was a case of poor direction and bad choices. If she does get this honor, which I doubt, will she perform live? I hope not. In the 70s and 80s she had a voice; sadly today she does not. It is painful to hear her today.
Posted by Liam on Monday, 02.11.08 @ 20:36pm
Wow...I don't think I've heard anything about her for a very long time, not even any airplay.
Posted by Terry on Monday, 02.11.08 @ 21:03pm
^^^Sabotage. That isn't me.
Posted by The Real Liam You All Know And Love on Tuesday, 02.12.08 @ 09:29am
...On the contrary Liam. I'm sure that Melanie would perform at her induction ceremony. She still tours extensively to this day, and her voice is superb. It's better than ever!!!
Posted by Bill Herrick on Sunday, 03.9.08 @ 19:40pm
OK, I'll admit, Melanie is a little crazy and has the worst management in the history of rock music (Is there an award for that?).
Posted by James Baldwin on Tuesday, 04.29.08 @ 11:21am
Melanie? Her chances? Slim to none. Although Melanie is an extremely talented artist who helped define a generation, her chances are zero. There's an old saying, " don't burn your bridges", Melanie and her mangement have burned many. Too many enemies in the business. If she was, by some miracle, nominated, there would be an "insider" revolt.
Posted by Reese on Sunday, 07.13.08 @ 10:34am
She was so adorable at the original and to my opinion the only Woodstock. She was so good and what a voice. My favorite song of her's is Candles in the Rain but all her songs are so beautiful. She should have been inducted long ago. She was the voice of a generation. I know her songs were inspiration to myself. INDUCED MELONANIE!
Posted by Genevieve on Thursday, 01.15.09 @ 11:08am
I LOVE HANOI JANE FONDA
Posted by OKTOBERFEST on Tuesday, 06.9.09 @ 19:08pm
The "Random Artist Page" button took me to Melanie's page where I was able to observe a comment by none other than "OKTOBERFEST" who claims he/she/it "Loves Hanoi Jane Fonda"
Posted by Keebord on Saturday, 09.5.09 @ 13:23pm
She deserves induction but there were great female singer-songwriters before her. Janis Ian Bobbie Gentry and Buffy St. Marie were even before Joni Mitchell's debut in 1968. Lay Down( Candles In the Rain) is as potent today as ever. Too bad 'Brand New Key' will alway be on her resume. To this day when I think of a Flower Child, Melanie always come to mind. Wish I could have see her at Woodstock, it seems like almost all artists on that historic venue have already been inducted.
Posted by skytorch on Sunday, 08.1.10 @ 03:13am
It is true that the "powers that be" don't like her. But then again who do they like? Not a single one of Melanie's peers are favored by anyone on the inside. She did her own thing - her way - she left corporate music to form her own label way, way before it was popular to do so. She was the first in so many ways - and she never sold out for the almighty buck. Listen to her resite what happened to her when she turned down Barry Manilow and Clive Davis on a "sexy" attempt at marketing her (single would have been "somewhere in the night). When she said no she was blacklisted in America and never had another top 40 hit. Guess you could say they are enemies of hers! They have all tried to take her down but she is still out there singing and entertaining to her hearts desire. I admire her for that - and so should anyone who "knows anything" about popular music. She deserves to be let in on so many levels that it makes your head spin. She won't get in though (at least not while she is alive) because no one deserving on a level that describes her credentials for inclusion - ever do.
Posted by Dwayne on Friday, 12.31.10 @ 20:46pm
Lay Down (Candles in the Rain)
Posted by Carole W on Monday, 01.23.12 @ 13:26pm
I had heard she had been blacklisted by the industry but didn't know why till I read your post Dwayne.
Posted by Zuzu on Saturday, 10.18.14 @ 23:24pm
Dear Melanie is in a recovery room right at this moment after having emergency surgery. She has performed here locally twice in the last week. Here spirit is the same all of these years but her heart is heavy for never being accepted my the RRHOF. It is her time. Let's get her in!
Posted by Jim Lange on Tuesday, 12.20.16 @ 22:27pm
This site is not affiliated with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum.